# Keith Jarrett said that to develop your own sound, you play stuff that you like and you don’t play stuff that you don’t like: Video, Notes

- Link: https://jazzblues.eu/2018/09/27/keith-jarrett-said-that-to-develop-your-own-sound-you-play-stuff-that-you-like-and-you-dont-play-stuff-that-you-dont-like-video-notes/
- Published: 2018-09-27T00:01:37+01:00
- Author: https://JazzBlues.EU

**Fall 2018: I’m headed back to my third year of private students at the New England
Conservatory of Music. At this point I have a worked up a fair number of “riffs”
that I automatically tell students, including the following…**

20th-Century jazz was the great music of the epoch, a combination of African and
European elements brought to a boil in the New World.

21st-Century jazz is more diverse than ever, but for me all great jazz will always
have elements that can be traced to Europe and Africa.

In the classroom, it seems like it is easier to talk about European matters, so 
jazz students usually have to dig deeper into the African side.

Somehow all great jazz is connected to the present day. What is happening _right
now_ informs relevant jazz.

Other elements are timeless. The blues doesn’t really change over time.

The blues aesthetic is often misunderstood by jazz students, who might think the
blues aesthetic means, “no rules,” “avoid the point,” or “let it happen.” It’s helpful
to remember a song from 1939 written by Sy Oliver and Trummy Young, “‘Tain’t What
You Do (It’s the Way That You Do It).”

A jazz master can play the exact same material as a novice….

![teaching 1.jpg](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/teaching-
1.jpg?w=640)

…but in the hands of the former, it sounds like the blues. In the hands of the latter,
it sounds corny.

It is helpful to work on simple, nearly corny material to get the general placement
right before proceeding to, “no rules,” “avoid the point,” or “let it happen.”

Joss Whedon said there were no new ideas, just new ways of putting together old 
ideas. I don’t think Whedon is entirely correct: Once in a great while, there _is_
a new idea. Still, Whedon must be mostly right.

Keith Jarrett said that to develop your own sound, you play stuff that you like 
and you don’t play stuff that you don’t like. That’s probably another way of saying
the same thing.

I am suspicious of jazz methodologies that offer a schedule more strict than these
banal Whedon and Jarrett aphorisms. Taste is up to you. If you love the music, you
have your taste. You will sound like yourself.

In a classroom situation, I don’t want to interfere with someone’s personal taste.
I prefer to work on the basics.

It’s very important to transpose, transpose, and transpose some more. Betty Carter
would audition pianists by asking them to play “Skylark” in an unusual key. Get 
away from the tyranny of seeing the black and white keys, and open up your ears 
to harmony in the abstract.

The hardest set of chord changes is not “Giant Steps” or something that moves around.
The hardest set of chord changes is “rhythm changes.” Anyone who studies with me
is told to play rhythm changes in all twelve keys as much as possible. Nothing has
helped me more than that basic exercise.

The left hand should know something about ragtime, stride, boogie woogie, and walking
bass lines. Lester Young once played for a dance with his unaccompanied tenor saxophone.
That was in the 1930s, when every pianist played for dancing. If I could enforce
such a policy, I’d have all my NEC students play for social dances.

Ragtime, stride, boogie woogie, and walking bass lines might seem anachronistic.
They are also technically difficult, and of course these days more often used solo
than with a band.

For “normal” modern jazz piano left hand it is good to practice certain classic 
patterns over and over again, especially patterns derived from clave sentences.

In each case below, a certain sentence offers a certain feeling. I named them for
famous pianists to help organize my own practice, but they were used by all the 
20th-century jazz piano greats. In the earlier era these sentences were in the right
hand against a stride, blues, or boogie bass. Beginning in the 50’s, they were in
the pianist’s left hand, working especially with the drummer’s left hand on the 
snare drum.

Good drummers got good by practicing their patterns, rudiments, and ride cymbal 
beats, over and over, for hours.

These four left hand piano patterns should be rigidly adhered to until they become
second nature. You should be able to have a verbal conversation with someone else
while playing these musical sentences accurately. In African music, there is less
separation between “living your life” and “making music” than in European music.

Once the patterns are second nature, the left hand will be much more free to play
whatever the hell it wants.

![LH rhythms](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/lh-rhythms.
jpg?w=640)

I advocate reading through piles of sheet music by obvious composers: Bach, Chopin,
Schumann, Brahms, Debussy, Scriabin, Ravel, Bartok, Schoenberg. One doesn’t have
to try the harder pieces, and you don’t have to get through anything on a professional
level. But many of the secrets of harmony are right there.

Sight-reading has been important to my career. I’ve gotten a few gigs because I 
could read something down when the next person in line couldn’t. On the other hand,
many of my all-time favorite jazz musicians couldn’t read music at all, let alone
read quickly. However, I think those non-paper people (Erroll Garner and Chet Baker
come to mind) were obvious geniuses. I guess if you are not such an obvious genius,
brushing up on your sight-reading is a good idea.

One person especially great to sight-read through is Scott Joplin. His harmonies
and melodies are exquisite and eternally fresh.

Jelly Roll Morton, James P. Johnson, Hank Jones, and Mary Lou Williams all recorded
Joplin with a swing beat. Indeed, I think ragtime performers from over a century
ago generally did not play Joplin with an even eighth. Playing Joplin with an even
eighth might have gotten firmly established in American culture with Marvin Hamlisch’s
score to the hit movie _The Sting_. Try swinging a bit as you leaf through a Joplin
book.

Speaking of Mary Lou Williams: In addition to being a wonderful pianist, Williams
was a real historian of the music. Her 1979 History of Jazz tree is profound document.

![Mary Lou tree](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/mary-lou-
tree.jpg?w=640)

There are a few dead branches, including “classical books.” Mary Lou Williams always
said that jazz was a feeling, and she was undoubtedly right. However, there’s no
way she could have written all those terrific arrangements for large ensembles without
training from “classical books.”  Perhaps by the time of her History of Jazz tree
she was frustrated by the some of the overtly European jazz sounds of the 50s, 60s,
and 70s.

At any rate, as much as I adore European classical music, I always try to bear Mary
Lou’s perspective in mind. One doesn’t want to kill off the jazz feeling with _too_much
European aesthetic.

The metronome does not exist in classical African musics. If you can already groove,
never pick up a metronome. A metronome does not help you swing. Milford Graves says
a metronome will give you a heart attack.

However, for most of us students, a bit of metronome can be a fun way to check ourselves
and keep focused. I don’t have an exact statistic at hand, but something like 99
out of 100 student jazz pianists rush a bit.

There’s no reason to have the metronome clicking away on every beat unless you are
true beginner. For the more advanced, I recommend two approaches, “slow” metronome
and “fast” metronome.

“Slow” is where there is one click every bar, or even every two bars. It is good
to put that click on “4” because it imitates Philly Joe Jones’s side-stick on many
tracks with Miles Davis.

Modern digital metronomes go down to 10 BPM. One click every six seconds: That’s
pretty slow. But 20 BPM is common in my own practice. It’s good to play a mix of
3s and 4s “against” it. After doing this for years, my time is definitely better.

The point is not to have precise time. Most of the people we really love to listen
to do not have precise time. Working with a metronome is an intermediate step. Clave
sentences are more important.

on “4” (40 BPM):

![teaching 3](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/teaching-3.
jpg?w=640)

even better, on every other “4” (20 BPM)

![teaching 4](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/teaching-4.
jpg?w=640)

“Fast” metronome puts the click on the upbeat. Playing a Charlie Parker bebop head
like “Ornithology” is revealing. This looks easy but…check it out. If you can do
it at 200 BPM I’ll be genuinely impressed. After practicing this for a few months
it was much easier for me to play with experienced drummers, like Billy Hart, who
play a lot of upbeats.

![teaching 2](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/teaching-2.
jpg?w=640)

—

Ben Street taught me an exercise called “feet in three.”

When we listen to a great bassist or drummer play straight quarter notes, there 
is something besides accurate time that makes their beat feel so good. It seems 
like there is a “glow” around their beat. Buster Williams and Ron Carter have this
glow in a particularly obvious way; so do Tony Williams and Jimmy Cobb. It’s not
the skip beats. You can find examples of Tony and Jimmy playing quarter notes on
the cymbal with no skip beats and the “glow” is still there.

In many classical African musics, there is a simultaneity of duple and triple.

So: If we are in 4/4, what about a “phantom” cross rhythm in 3?

Here’s the basic idea. Play the duples with your hands and the triples with your
feet. (I wrote in “left” and “right” here to make it extra clear but you could also
start with the left or tap with one foot.)

Listen to yourself play just the quarter notes with the hands, then add the triplets
in the feet. When the feet come in, it seems like the quarter notes take on another
kind of “glow.”

![feet in 3 1.jpg](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/feet-in-
3-1.jpg?w=640)

This might look easy, but I found it very hard to master. I don’t think any of my
students have really gotten it together yet.

I can personally attest that it helps. I was in some despair when I first started
playing with Tootie Heath, but after doing feet in three for a while, it was easier
to hook up with Tootie’s magnificent constellation of drums and cymbals.

A good “cheat” while getting it together is counting all the small value triples
phrased in four in the feet:

![feet 3 2](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/feet-3-2.jpg?
w=640)

After you can pull off straight quarter notes in the hands, try some clave rhythms
against the feet. Ouch. It’s also good to move the feet between four and three. 
Double ouch.

![feet 3 3](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/feet-3-3.jpg?
w=640)

Eventually you can try playing stride piano or bebop heads with the feet in three.
It really taught me something about swing. Indeed, I think this exercise borders
on pure magic. (This exercise can be done by any instrumentalist or singer with 
at least one foot.)

![feet moose](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/feet-moose.
jpg?w=640)

—

Forgetting feet in three:

Should you tap your feet on the beat while playing? Some famous jazz piano teachers
say no. On the other hand, almost every truly great jazz pianist does, especially
the ones that swing the hardest. Check the videos.

Probably you don’t want to tap on two and four. It is better to tap on one and three
or every beat. Two and four is already a “displacement,” and you want to feel steady.
Check the videos. I don’t think you can find a consecrated legend who taps on two
and four. (Let me know if you find one!)

I guess you don’t want to tap too loudly, unless it is an intentional special effect.
When Duke Ellington played solo or duo, he often tapped so loud that he had a percussion
section to bounce the syncopations off of, and I suspect that effect was intentional.

On a related topic: When leading a group, don’t count off in a big fashion. Be discreet
or just start. It’s what the masters did.

For DTM I have done a fair amount of transcribing and it has helped my ears improve.
I regret not doing more transcriptions when I was younger.

It also helps to sing solos. Lee Konitz and Henry Threadgill both told me to sing.
I’m a terrible singer, but now I can scat many Louis Armstrong, Lester Young, Charlie
Parker, and Bud Powell solos. In the 21st century, it is easy to make a repeating
playlist of just the solo or solos you are learning and walk around humming them
softly with your earphones. You might look like an idiot but the musical benefits
are undeniable.

Piano technique is a difficult topic. I rarely address it with students because 
there is so much to do with just musical content. Also, I think that most jazz pianists
sort of find their way with the instrument.

I am the most un-athletic person in the world, but I have been blessed with some
great technique teachers, especially Sophia Rosoff (a disciple of Abby Whiteside)
and John Bloomfield (a disciple of Dorothy Taubman).

In the end we want to play the piano with our whole body, not just our fingers. 
The image of a small gear and a big gear might be helpful.

If you want to spin those gears 10,000 times, you would instinctively grab the bigger
dowel to attach to the camshaft. Yes, you could attach the smaller dowel, and it
would probably work for a while. But for 10,000 times…

The little gear is your fingers, the big gear is the arm. The most obvious way to
power the fingers from a bigger gear is rotation from the wrist, although the whole
arm has to move laterally as well.

“Reaching” with the fingers (disconnected from the wrist and arm) should be avoided
as it really prioritizes the little gear. If someone is reaching a lot with their
fingers I think of them as a “digital” kind of player.

A lot of the greatest pianists are digital players. Genius does what it wants. Sports
doctors talk about how many of the best athletes have the most astonishing “work-
arounds” within their body, doing things all wrong from a holistic point of view,
yet somehow generating maximum strength and speed.

Athletes quit early. In most of the performing arts, youthful virtuosity gives way
to the long grind. Many pianists play in a “whatever works” sort of fashion in their
teens and twenties. When they get past thirty, the youthful virtuosity fades away
and is replaced with either mature confidence or something more like struggle.

Bud Powell and Herbie Hancock have a good relationship to the whole mechanism. Their
fingers look like they fall easily on to the keys without strain. Herbie brags about
not practicing very much, but it seems like he can always sit down at a moment’s
notice and deal out some burning jazz piano.

No one played better than McCoy Tyner, but he based his technique on furious finger
strength. At some point he just couldn’t keep it up. More recently, Geri Allen also
offered the most beautiful playing of her illustrious career early on.  In the mid-
1990s something quicksilver and abstract in her sound was replaced with something
comparatively restrained. Many people think it was a stylistic choice but I suspect
simply the way her hands felt over time was also a factor. To be clear: I love all
of McCoy Tyner and Geri Allen…but they are also two who also look exceptionally 
digital on video when young.

In classical music, both Glenn Gould and Vladimir Horowitz had frankly terrible 
digital habits at the keyboard, and the way they struggled had an adverse influence
on their enormous careers. Whatever you do, don’t imitate the physical characteristics
of Gould or Horowitz! (But it is perfectly OK to be inspired by their stunning discographies.)

Arthur Rubinstein and Martha Argerich are two who look much more relaxed, controlling
the sound from the bigger muscles. Like Herbie Hancock, they both bragged about 
not practicing very much.

This topic is a bit less important in jazz overall. Indeed, one way to get a more
African kind of aesthetic out of the instrument is to treat it as tuned percussion.
Sophia told me she thought Thelonious Monk was a tap dancer at the piano. Still,
we all want to play in a healthy fashion for our whole lives. If one feels uncomfortable
tension while playing, it is something to be addressed sooner rather than later.

![5000 fingers](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2018/09/5000-fingers.
jpg?w=640&h=339&fit=452%2C339)

### _Related_
