# A surrealist painter who collaborated with the Chicago jazz scene: Pictures, Video

- Link: https://jazzblues.eu/2018/10/04/a-surrealist-painter-who-collaborated-with-the-chicago-jazz-scene-pictures-video/
- Published: 2018-10-04T00:01:43+01:00
- Author: https://JazzBlues.EU

**The story of how the 20th century artist, Gertrude Abercrombie, was entrenched
in the depths of Chicago’s dark, turbulent, discriminatory, social, and political
reality.**

Who is Gertrude Abercrombie? An exhibition and its book — the first show of her 
work in New York since 1952, organized by Dan Nadel — is here to introduce you. 
Abercrombie (1909-1977) is a surrealist painter who lived and worked in Chicago 
in the mid-twentieth century.

As the “Gertrude Stein of the Midwest,” Abercrombie reigned over the cultural scene
of Chicago’s Hyde Park neighborhood from the 1930s to the 1970s, where she held 
lively dinner parties and salons that included many of the city’s legendary jazz
musicians, writers, and artists.  In fact, James Purdy based one of the characters
in his novel _Malcom _(1959) off of Abercrombie herself (which then became the basis
of Edward Albee’s play of the same title), Ernst Krenek composed one of his operas
while renting the second floor of her home (likely Dark Waters (1950)), and in 1956
pianist Richie Powell composed “Gertrude’s Bounce” in her honor, which he recorded
with Max Roach, Sonny Rollins, Clifford Brown, and George Morrow, all of whom were
regular guests at her gatherings.

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-39-001-1080x848.
jpg?resize=640%2C503&ssl=1)

Gertrude Abercrombie, “Landscape with Church” (1939), (courtesy Karma, New York,
collection of Laura and Gary Maurer)

Abercrombie’s home also offered a safe-space for collaborations between artists,
musicians, and writers of varying racial and sexual identities at a time when such
spaces were as rare as they were important. In a note from her close friend, writer
Karl Priebe, the tension of this era and the importance of Abercrombie’s friendship
and support in the face of poignant hatred and discrimination is particularly clear.
Priebe was openly gay and in an interracial relationship, a situation in the 1940s
which necessitated great attention and care to protect himself and his partner, 
Frank Roy Harriet. In response to an invitation to join Abercrombie at a party, 
Priebe replies, “You made me so happy by writing. Here is the problem so answer.
Frank H. is living with me and is colored and if we can come in the face of that
we will. I mean — if Aidan’s place will allow, then definitely we will be there.
So find out and write and we’ll appear. I would love to see you so report.”

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-47-003-1080x899.
jpg?resize=640%2C533&ssl=1)

Gertrude Abercrombie, “Reverie” (1947), (photo Illinois State Museum, courtesy Karma,
New York, Illinois State Museum, Illinois Legacy Collection, museum purchase)

One of Abercrombie’s closest relationships was with Dizzy Gillespie, with whom she
shared a friendship throughout her adult life. Shortly before her death in 1977,
_Chicago Magazine_ published an article on Gillespie and Abercrombie, wherein the
two were photographed and interviewed together. Gillespie is credited there with
calling Abercrombie’s work “bop” art, a story that Abercrombie herself discredits
in an interview with Studs Terkel shortly thereafter. As Abercrombie explains, “
No. That wasn’t quite right. I told him that I invented the term ‘bop’ for my art
because there is a thing called op art and there’s a thing called pop art but I 
said mine is bop art. I just invented that term in the arts sense but oh no, no,
he and Charlie did the bop for music… I think they’re called bop paintings, yes,
because they’re a little off, not color but off, kind of off the beam, they’re kind
of goofy. I feel that they’re like the bop music.”

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-48-003-1080x925.
jpg?resize=640%2C548&ssl=1)

Gertrude Abercrombie, “Star and Crescent” (1948), (courtesy Karma, New York, Illinois
State Museum)

Abercrombie’s interest in creating “bop” art highlights an important aspect of the
art scene in Chicago at that time — the interest to interpret the contemporary, 
modernist principles as an invitation to react to the political and cultural climate
of the era with independent and unique artistic responses. For Abercrombie, this
meant creating paintings that were intellectually strong, based on studied responses
to art historical narratives, but nevertheless full of personal resonance, deriving
from her own interior consciousness and the exterior scenes of her personal, daily
life. As Robert Cozzolino describes in his essay, “The Sorceress in the Center of
Everything,” included in Karma’s recent monograph of Abercrombie’s work, Abercrombie
lived “the life she wanted, free of society’s prejudices, surrounding herself with
people on McCarthy-era America’s margins.”

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-56-001-1080x920.
jpg?resize=640%2C545&ssl=1)

Gertrude Abercrombie, “Owl and a Tornado” (1956), (courtesy Karma, New York, collection
of Laura and Gary Maurer)

Accordingly, Karma’s exhibition text and accompanying monograph focus primarily 
on Abercrombie’s relevance within the social fabric of South Chicago and on the 
deeply personal nature of her thematic and iconographic choices, which can be seen
in the imagery that populates her small-scale paintings. With the exception of two
self-portraits, one produced as a watercolor, “Self Portrait Watercolor” (c. 1940)
and one as a miniature clay sculpture, “Self Portrait”_ (_c. 1945), the exhibition
itself is organized as a fairly straightforward, chronological retrospective of 
68 oil paintings that offers a view into the development of Abercrombie’s oeuvre
between 1934 and 1971.

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GertrudeAbercrombie_InstallationView_01-
720x540.jpg?resize=640%2C480&ssl=1)

Installation view (courtesy Karma, New York)

By beginning with a piece from 1934, the exhibition opens with a reminder of the
fraught historical context in which Abercrombie began her career — in the Midwest,
during the Great Depression — when she became involved with the Public Works of 
Art Project (PWAP) and the Federal Art Project (FAP), both programs within the Works
Progress Administration (WPA). The following decades weren’t better. As Cozzolino
points out, in 1955 Emmett Till’s home was only two miles from hers and his tragedy
was surely felt deeply by Abercrombie and her community. According to Cozzolino,
Abercrombie has even explained, “I paint the way I do because I’m just plain scared…
I mean, I think it’s a scream that we’re alive today, don’t you?”

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-54-003-1080x933.
jpg?resize=640%2C553&ssl=1)

Gertrude Abercrombie, “Queen and Owl in Tree” (1954), (courtesy Karma, New York,
Illinois State Museum, Illinois Legacy Collection, museum purchase)

As this exhibition demonstrates, when it comes to Abercrombie’s paintings, they 
are perhaps even more mysterious and compelling than the figure herself. Beyond 
serving as a reflection of the interiority of a troubled woman in a constant rebellion
against her place in an unjust world, Abercrombie’s paintings are charming, magnetizing,
and — despite their undoubted scariness — really funny. Relatively small (and sometimes
tiny) paintings repeat simple depictions of moons, towers, cats, barren trees, owls,
hats, shells, snails, doors, and many, many iterations of herself.

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-ND-003-1080x912.
jpg?resize=640%2C540&ssl=1)

Gertrude Abercrombie, “Untitled (Woman sitting on a log)” (n.d.), (courtesy Karma,
New York, Illinois State Museum, Illinois Legacy Collection, Gift of the Gertrude
Abercrombie Trust)

This can be seen clearly with the example of Abercrombie’s _“Wall and Giraffe”_ (
1951), which presents a white, brick wall with a small hole, just large enough for
a head to peer through from behind. In front of the wall is a giraffe, whose head
is just high enough to look over the wall to see the girl on the other side. Do 
they realize they can see one another? What is the purpose of this barrier separating
them, this _white wall_, and does the sweet optimism with which the giraffe and 
girl study one another imply the possibility of transcending the boundary to become
friends? Without wanting to pull too great a political reading out of such a light-
hearted, fantastical painting, the depiction can’t help but recall Robert Storr’s
ruminations on Abercrombie’s life in Chicago and the notable absence of any marks
of racial struggle found in the photographs of her and her friends. Storr writes,“
the insurmountable inequalities, latent tensions, and corrosive mistrust inherent
in crossing the boundary from either direction are not apparent on Abercrombie’s
face or the faces of her companions. Whether she was simply unaware of their existence
and the jazz men simply ignored an ache they almost certainly felt, or whether collectively
they had transcended their differences is impossible to know for sure.”  Additionally,
the redundant nature of Abercrombie’s canvases accentuates her restrained pallet
and amplifies the eeriness of her subject matter.

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-61-002-1080x954.
jpg?resize=640%2C565&ssl=1)

Gertrude Abercrombie, “Doors with Black Cat” (1961), (courtesy Karma, New York, 
private collection, New York)

In certain cases, the theme of redundancy is itself latent in Abercrombie’s paintings.“
_Untitled (Blue Screen, Black Cat, Print of Same)” (_c. 1945), presents an image
of a room in which there is a cat walking behind a screen and a painting on the 
wall that depicts the same room with a cat walking out from behind the same screen.
Similarly, Abercrombie’s paintings of different colored doors address fundamental
questions about repetition as it pertains to daily life, in a simple, clever, and
direct way. Abercrombie’s use of repetition, while offering a calming, still quality
to the exhibition, also addresses a stoic quality that she upheld within her own
life: each day is largely the same, but the future holds the potential for difference
and change if one can imagine it.

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-63-003-1080x1256.
jpg?resize=640%2C744&ssl=1)

Gertrude Abercrombie, “St. Brigit” (1963), (courtesy Karma, New York, private collection)

Finally, Abercrombie’s paintings offer a foil for understanding just how masculine
the general conception of twentieth century surrealist art remains. That said, the
weight of any systematic attempt to re-appropriate historical legacies fraught with
injustice and discontent is notably missing from Abercrombie’s delicate, otherworldly
canvases. As with _“Wall with Giraffe” — _Abercrombie’s work straddles the tension
between that which is simple, magical, and free, and that which is turbulent, dark,
and unavoidable — the beauty of a moment of friendship and the reality of a wall
in between. What is perhaps most astounding about Abercrombie, and lends such depth
to her simple canvases, is the tension that she herself embodied: entrenched in 
the depths of Chicago’s dark, turbulent, discriminatory, social and political reality,
Abercrombie created the possibility for a daily life that promoted generosity, freedom,
and collaboration. As Abercrombie explained, “Surrealism is meant for me because
I am a pretty realistic person but don’t like all I see. So I dream that it is changed.
Then I change it to the way I want it.”

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-34-001-1080x965.
jpg?resize=640%2C572&ssl=1)

Gertrude Abercrombie, “Untitled (Slaughterhouse at Aledo)” (1934), (photo courtesy
Illinois State Museum, courtesy Karma, New York, Illinois State Museum, Illinois
Legacy Collection, Gift of the Gertrude Abercrombie Trust)

This ability to re-construct the world according to her own vision enabled Abercrombie
to re-frame her reality within the walls of her Victorian home in Hyde Park, where
she could design and produce opportunities for others to share in her vision. Abercrombie’s
paintings, each one carefully contained within a beautiful and unusual frame, serve
as a reminder of the importance in re-imagining the world to be the place you want
it to be by demonstrating the forceful power in deciding to recreate your world 
according to the image you imagine. Abercrombie imagined herself as a person, a 
friend, and a collaborator beyond the violence and discrimination of the era’s societal
norms, as a surrealist painter “sui generis,” and ultimately as an example of a 
strong, unique-minded, creative individual who knew how to paint, really well. It
is about time that we remember her.

Gertrude Abercrombie_ is on view until September 23 at Karma (188 East 2nd Street,
East Village, New York)._

![](https://i0.wp.com/hyperallergic.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/GA-41-001-1080x1070.
jpg?resize=640%2C634&ssl=1)

### _Related_
