# The social effects of Jazz: Video

- Link: https://jazzblues.eu/2018/12/18/the-social-effects-of-jazz-video/
- Published: 2018-12-18T19:47:18+01:00
- Author: https://JazzBlues.EU

**This paper’s purpose is to examine the social effects of jazz music. It focuses
on the exploitation of black jazz musicians by whites in the industry and looks 
at whether black musicians benefited at all from their innovations. **

Many of today’s African American musicians are faced with similar social circumstances
as those of past jazz musicians and as a result, the importance of the African American
culture is still being ignored. Despite the negative social conditions that blacks
faced, some blacks were still able to benefit and gained respect, stardom, and recognition
for being the inventors of jazz music.

Where words fail, music speaks,” says the poet Hans Christian Andersen. This message
is profoundly expressed in jazz music. In the 1920s, jazz experienced a rise in 
popularity when the music began to spread through recordings. Some black jazz musicians
believe that they were ripped off financially and that they did not get full recognition
and compensation for being the inventors of jazz as African American culture. Furthermore,
some people oppose the idea that jazz was invented by blacks. Jazz music as such
became more of a commodity than an art and the highest achievers were white.

Music is essential to the African American experience in the United States. Faced
with racism, discrimination, and segregation, blacks have always found comfort and
a sense of peace in their music. Music continues to be a means by which the anger,
grief, compassion and desire for change is transformed into positive energy for 
blacks (Dawson, 2001). Today, the social conditions facing American popular music,
especially rap, are analogous to those faced by jazz music, and many musicians have
similar experiences. Despite the fact that jazz music has created some positive 
social effects, it has created more negative ones for black jazz musicians, such
as exploitation and jazz appropriation, some of which are still occurring today.

In order to understand the social effects of jazz music, there must be an understanding
of how this music came into existence. I will then discuss the positive and the 
negative effects jazz had on black jazz musicians. Jazz developed from Afro-American
music which included: Work songs, spiritual music, minstrelsy (a stage entertainment
usually performed by whites with blackened faces who performed songs, dances and
comedy ostensibly of black American origin), and other forms (Wheaton, 1994). Dorsey(
2001) believes that black music and black musical accomplishments have been rooted
in the continent of Africa. Jazz’s relationship to African music can be demonstrated
in “the dominance of percussion in African American music…and bending the notes 
expressed in improvisation” (p. 36). The same way Africans were able to spontaneously
invent a piece of music or beat, sometimes without any instruments, black jazz musicians
are able to incorporate some of these features in their music. The improvisational
style of the latter is very much influenced by the former, and is a unique feature
of jazz music.

Furthermore, jazz is considered an integral part of African American culture. Though
there has been great debate about a standard definition of jazz, Wheaton (1994) 
believes it “can be defined as a combination of improvisatory styles with western
European form and harmony” (p. 90). In other words, despite jazz’s African roots,
it also has many European features such as composition, internal structure, and 
harmony. Peretti (1992) too states that jazz obtained its musical identity from 
the African and European traditions. Jazz music emerged out of “hot music” from 
New Orleans at the turn of the twentieth century and some of the structures were
inherited from Africa and passed down to blacks from slavery to freedom (Dorsey,
2001). Jazz categories include Dixieland, swing, bop, cool jazz, hard bop, free 
jazz, Third Stream, jazz-rock, and fusion (Wheaton, 1994). The first jazz-style 
to receive recognition as a fine art was bebop, which is mainly instrumental and
was formed by serious black jazz musicians who experimented with new ideas in the
late night jam sessions (Wheaton, 1994). Bebop evolved in the 1940s and was said
to have been created by blacks in a way that whites could not copy (Gerard, 1998).

The history of jazz proves that black musicians are the inventors and innovators
of jazz, and that has been a major accomplishment of blacks. According to Wheaton(
1994), an innovator’s “job is not to entertain, but rather, to make the listener
aware and to force the audience to confront often disturbing realities and hidden
truths about themselves, their society and their world” (p. 143). Jazz is often 
referred to as “Black classical music.” Gerard (1998) cites Amiri Baraka, who first
argued that jazz is an African American music in his book Blues People (1963), and
also called jazz “Black music” in books he wrote later. In fact, one of the first
musicians to label his music “Negro music” was Duke Ellington, who made it a priority
to express the African American culture profoundly in it (Gerard, 1998). Mackey (
1992) believes that blacks were cheated out of their invention of jazz music. In
other words, commercial success was only obtained by whites. Blacks were basically
locked out of it. Yet most white jazz musicians did not have the improvisational
skills or originality that the black musicians displayed in their music. Malcolm
X says that whites simply replicate what they heard in the past, whereas blacks “
could spontaneously invent.” He states:

I’ve seen black musicians when they’d be jamming at a jam session with white musicians—
a whole lot of difference. The white musician can jam if he’s got some sheet music
in front of him…But that black musician, he picks up his horn and starts blowing
some sounds that he never thought of before. He improvises, he creates. (qtd. in
Gerard, 1998, p. 78)

However, there are opposing points of view when it comes to who invented jazz. Textbook
writer Frank Tirro writes: “contrary to popular belief, jazz does not owe its existence
to any one race” (qtd. in Gerard, 1998, p.88). Because of the western influences
and American band traditions in jazz, some people believe that it does not simply
belong to African Americans. In addition, in response to the statement that whites
stole the music, Jim Hall says, “I’ve always felt that the music started out as 
black but that it’s as much mine now as anyone else’s. I haven’t stolen the music
from anybody—I just bring something different to it” (qtd. in Gerard, 1998, p. 90).
Hall is indeed acknowledging that blacks invented jazz, but he does not feel that
whites have stolen it, even if whites imitated the various jazz styles created by
blacks and became wealthy as a result.

Upward social mobility among black jazz musicians is a very significant factor, 
though it was not common. Opportunities were given to black musicians by the radio
and recording industry and popular black bands were promoted as long as there was
a demand for jazz music by white Americans (Gerard, 1998). However, Mackey (1992)
believes that there was a containment of black mobility on the political level and
that the social and economic progress blacks might have accumulated because of their
artistic innovation was blocked by whites. Black jazz musicians were primarily from
the lower class. As Means (1968) points out, despite their social background, “some
of these jazzmen received recognition as serious composers and several conducted
well-known symphony orchestras and were invited to give concerts in Carnegie Hall(
p. 18). Benny Goodman, a white jazz bandleader, brought to stardom Teddy Wilson,
Lionel Hampton and Charlie Christian, but still encountered criticism for benefiting
from their talents; a few other black jazz musicians, including Louis Armstrong 
and Duke Ellington, made a lot of money (Gerard, 1998).

Jazz music has created a sense of integration between blacks and whites in the industry.
Buster Bailey, a black jazz musician said, “One thing I’m happy to see is the integration
that’s happening among musicians” (qtd. in Means, 1968, p. 22). Discrimination still
existed, but in the jazz community, musicians were somehow considered as equals.
Whites were hired to perform in several black bands and the white trombonist Roswell
Rudd was introduced to jazz audiences by Archie Shepp (Gerard, 1998). Means (1968)
cites Monroe Berger who notes that jazz music created black-white contact where 
a black musician received full acceptance as an equal and was “(often admired as
superior) without condescension” (Means, 1998, p. 17). Jazz music has not only integrated
people in the United States, but also brought them together internationally. It 
has been influenced by third world countries such as Latin America, Africa, the 
Middle East, and India (Wheaton, 1994). Great jazz musicians integrated international
ideas into their music; for instance, Duke Ellington has an album named Far East
Suite, and two of Coltrane’s albums are named Africa and India (Wheaton, 1994).

Today, jazz music is progressing in many ways. Despite its economic decline and 
struggle to survive because of the developed wealth of rock and pop, there have 
been many opportunities for the survival of jazz. Jazz began to penetrate the music
programs of high schools, colleges and universities right after World War II, and
in 1968, the International Association of Jazz Education was formed (Wheaton, 1994).
Ron Dewey Wynn, co-founder and executive director of the Mill Street Jazz and Culture
Society in Philadelphia, teaches inner city kids to appreciate the history and training
in jazz music and calls jazz “African American Classical Improvisational Music” (
Dawson, 2001). He contends that African American children won’t experience jazz 
culture as music programs decrease in schools around the country (Dawson, 2001).
Jazz has also gotten much recognition in the United States and around the world 
through jazz festivals. Overseas festivals have been more successful than festivals
in the United States; in places like Switzerland, the Netherlands and Italy, jazz
festivals have all broken records for attendance (Wheaten, 1994).

Now that the positive social effects of jazz have been clarified, I will present
the negative effects. The recording industry has played a major role in the commercialization
of jazz music, which has led to uniformity. Jazz music would not have been widely
distributed to the general public without the recording industry, and it provided
a perfect opportunity for making the music more marketable. As a result, blacks 
were socially affected, and according to Means (1968), they had limited opportunities
to showcase their originality and were forced to create music that appealed only
to whites. However, white bands had a sense of sameness that was more marketable.
According to Mackey (1992), swing music lacked improvisation, and the soloist’s 
creativity was not relied upon as much because of the commercialization of the music.
Jazz became so commercialized that the industry was less dependent on black innovation,
but rather produced a music that was lacking the essence of jazz—its improvisation.
Baraka quotes Hsio wen Shih’s “comments regarding the anthology album The Great 
Swing Bands, a record Shih refers to as ‘terrifying’ due to the indistinguishability
of one band from another” (qtd. in Mackey, 1992, p. 60). Swing music basically lacked
creativity and distinction and as a result, swing bands sounded alike.

Black jazz musicians were less credited for their invention and innovation of jazz
music. Jazz music created a sense of identity, originality, and social cohesion 
among black musicians, but they were seldom credited with inventing it. Kofsky (
1998) believes that this refusal of whites to credit blacks is because they refused
to equate anything valuable with African Americans. According to Miles Davis, this
is the case because “the white man likes to win everything. White people like to
see other white people win…and they can’t win when it comes to jazz…because black
people created this” (qtd. in Gerard, 1998, p.16). In addition, whites became more
famous than blacks because of their unwillingness to give blacks credit for their
talents. Means (1968) too believes that black jazz musicians experienced a lot of
resentment because they felt that they did not always receive acknowledgement for
their accomplishments, while whites were granted titles such as “King of Swing” 
and “King of Jazz” (p.18). Again this social effect of jazz was a result of greed
by whites, and it created anger, fear and resentment among black jazz musicians.

While whites in the jazz music industry got rich, black musicians did not reap equal
benefits. The industry caused a great deal of exploitation and discrimination by
whites against blacks. Rex Stewart says, “Where the control is, the money is. Do
you see any of us running any record companies, booking agencies, radio stations,
music magazines?” (qtd. in Kofsky, 1998, p. 19). In other words, the recording/distribution
industry was in complete control, not black musicians. Because of this power and
contempt for black art, blacks were likely to suffer and the recording industry 
basically determined the economic success or failure of an artist. White musicians
who benefited from the talent of black musicians were labeled exploiters and for
the financial gain they drew from the music, they were called thieves (Gerard, 1998,
p. 14). For instance, arrangements were purchased from black musicians by Benny 
Goodman, a white jazz musician known as “King of Swing.” However, the majority of
black musicians, despite their invention of the music, experienced very little success(
Mackey, 1992). Mackey (1992) further states that “the most popular and best-paid
bands were white” and with the development of radio, which was an excellent form
for publicizing the music, the best paid studio jobs were predominantly secured 
by whites (p. 52). In other words, because of race, black jazz musicians have experienced
great disadvantages throughout the history of jazz music (Means, 1968).

Furthermore, the jazz music industry contributed a great deal to the continuous 
victimization of blacks. Whites continued to exploit black jazz musicians for financial
gain, even in death. For instance, a month after Bessie Smith died, John Hammond,
an employee of Columbia Records, wrote an article in Down Beat magazine saying that“
a special Bessie Smith memorial album will be released…and this will be the best
buy of the year in music” (qtd. in Kofsky, 1998, p. 33). Evidently he was more interested
in promoting his fame and fortune than paying respect to the dead. However, Hammond
frequently referred to himself as being the protector of black artists to increase
his reputation (Kofsky).

Another social effect that was pivotal in jazz was the social stigma associated 
with the music, not only by whites, but also by blacks. This stigma created an environment
for black exploitation because jazz was considered black folk music. The stigma 
consisted of a belief held by whites that the tradition of African American music
was not art, but was rather artistically worthless, trivial and only tolerated for
profitability (Levine, 1989). For instance, “Jazz Must Go,” was the title of an 
article published in 1921 in the Ladies Home Journal (Means, 1968). Peretti (1992)
also states that the exploitation of that era was typical and was only for the purpose
of profitability. However, in the twentieth century, while jazz was being rejected
in the United States, African American jazz musicians received many opportunities
overseas. Their artistic ability was acknowledged and encouraged and they discovered
that segregation was not widespread (Ross, 2001). Ross further states that though
the music had originated in the United States, because of its carrier, “the so-called
negros,” the dominant group (whites) quickly condemned it.

Likewise, in the 1920s, jazz was thought of as “a backward, low form of expression”
by reputable blacks from Oklahoma City, said the black novelist Ralph Ellison (qtd.
in Means, 1968, p. 334). For instance, C.J. Handy’s father told him “he would rather
see him dead than become a jazz musician” (Means, 1968, p. 334). One must wonder
what brought on this negative view of jazz among blacks. Was it the race factor?
Yes, it was. Means relates the views of E. Franklin Frazier and LeRoi Jones, who
believed the main reason was that middle class blacks wanted to fit into white society.
They repudiated jazz because they thought it was too much a part of black slave 
heritage (Means). Individual blacks have tried to assimilate into the American mainstream
by achieving high levels of education; however, assuming the mainstream culture 
meant abandoning or destroying their own culture (Baskerville, 2003). Gerard (1998)
adds that black musicians and the black middle class ceased to be ashamed of their
culture with the civil rights movement and became proud of jazz music.

Jazz music has not only created negative social conditions, but has also been a 
force for racial integration, respect, and social mobility. Social mobility proves
to be a very significant factor because it showcases a similarity between black 
jazz musicians and black rap artists in terms of their accomplishments in obtaining
wealth and stardom because of the invention of their music. Jazz should be given
more recognition and should be studied in more high schools and colleges in the 
United States so that students, particularly black students, can be educated about
its origins.

The origins of jazz music have been in much dispute and have caused many controversies.
Though people may argue that jazz music was not exclusively invented by blacks, 
the fact remains that the great innovators of the music are indeed blacks. Gerard(
1998) notes that African-American ideologists become offended “that each style of
jazz—and each variety of blues, rhythms-and-blues, and rap, for that matter—have
been appropriated from the African-American community almost the day after it was
first heard there” (p. 14). As classical music is clearly European, jazz music should
undoubtedly be considered African-American music.

#### References

Baskerville, J. D. (2003). The impact of black nationalist ideology on American 
jazz music of the 1960s and 1970s. Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press.

Dawson, N. J. (2001). Can you sing jazz? Perception and appreciation of jazz music
among African American young adults. In J. L. Conyers, Jr. (Ed.), African American
jazz and rap: Social and philosophical examinations of black expressive behavior(
pp. 201-210). Jefferson, NC: McFarland.

Dorsey, L. (2001). “And all that jazz” has African roots! In J. L. Conyers, Jr. (
Ed.), African American jazz and rap: Social and philosophical examinations of black
expressive behavior (pp. 35-54). Jefferson, NC: McFarland.

Gerard, C. (1998). Jazz in black and white: Race, culture, and identity in the jazz
community. Westport, CT: Praeger.

Kofsky, F. (1998). Black music, white music: Illuminating the history and political
economy of jazz. New York: Pathfinder.

Levine, L. W. (1989). Jazz and American culture. The Journal of American Folklore,
102(403), 6-22. Retrieved October 23, 2008, from JSTOR database.

Mackey, N. (1992). Other: From noun to verb. Representations 39, 51-70. Retrieved
October 28, 2008, from JSTOR database.

Means, R. L. (1968). Notes on Negro jazz: 1920-1950: The use of biographical materials
in sociology. The Sociological Quarterly 9(3), 332-342. Retrieved November 5, 2008,
from JSTOR database.

Peretti, B. W. (1992). The creation of jazz: Music, race, and culture in urban America.
Urbana: University of Illinois Press.

Ross, L. (2001). Jazz musicians in postwar Europe and Japan. In J. L. Conyers, Jr.(
Ed.), African American jazz and rap: Social and philosophical examinations of black
expressive behavior (pp. 90-116). Jefferson, NC: McFarland.

Thomas, R. (2001). The rhythm of rhyme: A look at rap music as an art form from 
a jazz perspective. In J. L. Conyers, Jr. (Ed.), African American jazz and rap: 
Social and philosophical examinations of black expressive behavior (pp. 163-169).
Jefferson, NC: McFarland.

Wheaton, J. (1994). All that jazz! New York: Ardsley House.

![ÐÐ°ÑÑÐ¸Ð½ÐºÐ¸ Ð¿Ð¾ Ð·Ð°Ð¿ÑÐ¾ÑÑ The social effects of Jazz](https://i0.wp.
com/www.thoughtco.com/thmb/UPch-ptHdhMquN7DyjZuRccGG6A%3D/768x0/filters%3Ano_upscale%
28%29%3Amax_bytes%28150000%29%3Astrip_icc%28%29/3295501-56a549d43df78cf77287709d.
jpg?w=640&ssl=1)

### _Related_
