# Bill Evans on Miles Davis and Kind of Blue: Video

- Link: https://jazzblues.eu/2019/06/01/bill-evans-on-miles-davis-and-kind-of-blue-video/
- Published: 2019-06-01T18:13:18+01:00
- Author: https://JazzBlues.EU

**[https://allan-chase.com ](https://allan-chase.com)I’ve been looking forward to
sharing this informative interview with Bill Evans for a long time. It seems to 
me that it contains some valuable and possibly unique insights and details about
the compositions and recording of _Kind of Blue_ and Evans’s views on and relationship
with Miles Davis.**

The interview was broadcast on July 4, 1979, shortly after it was recorded (at Bill
Evans’s apartment, exact date unknown) as part of the 126-hour Miles Davis Festival
on WKCR FM, the Columbia University station in New York City. There are other interviews
from the festival online, including an equally interesting Phil Schaap interview
of Jimmy Cobb.

I’m not aware of another source that gives this much first-hand detail about the
compositions, how they were made and taught, what was written down by whom, and 
what parts were spontaneously created.

Despite a handful of memory slips or inaccurate details, I feel Bill Evans is as
reliable a source in this interview as anyone could reasonably be expected to be
20 years after a recording session. He recalled that the album was recorded in one
afternoon (“as far as I can remember”), when it was actually two sessions about 
seven weeks apart. But no one involved knew what _Kind of Blue_ was going to be 
when those record dates happened. They were significant sessions, since Evans was
called back to the band he had left, but each was also just another day in the studio
for busy musicians, and many such days in jazz musicians’ careers led to unreleased
material. (I wonder if McCoy Tyner remembers he did a Milt Jackson recording date
on the same day as _A Love Supreme_.* Of course, there was more than one attempt
at recording _A Love Supreme_, and they didn’t know that was the one then, either.)

Evans says the album was entirely first takes, and consisted of the only complete
takes, which was commonly believed at the time, although we now know that there’s
a complete alternate take of “Flamenco Sketches.” He doesn’t mention that the line
used as an introduction to “So What” was written by Gil Evans, but it’s possible
he never knew that, or didn’t think to mention it. The story of “Blue in Green” 
has been told in a little more detail elsewhere — see my footnote** at the bottom
of this post.

Here it is. Enjoy!

Audio:Audio Player

**Bill Evans Interview**

Interview taped by Bill Goldberg at Bill Evans’s Fort Lee, NJ apartment, not at 
radio studio

**Interviewer: William Goldberg**; shared with his written permission

2nd Interviewer: Eddie Karp (according to Ashley Kahn)

Only known broadcast: July 4, 1979 on WKCR-FM, New York City as part of the 126-
hour _Miles Davis Festival_

From an audio cassette taped off the air live by Lewis Nash, listening in Bronxville
NY. Digitized from a copy of the cassette in late 1990s. Transcribed by Allan Chase,
3/24/19-5/8/19.

INTERVIEWER WILLIAM (BILL) GOLDBERG: And [in] this portion of the Miles Davis Festival,
we’re fortunate to have with us pianist-composer Bill Evans, and Bill was with Miles
in the late fifties, and, well, he was on that classic recording _Kind of Blue,_
which is still probably one of the best-selling jazz records. And, [it’s] funny,
yesterday, I was calling up these record stores, ‘cause I’m doing this research 
on what was the best-selling things for this organization, NYC Jazz, and, other 
than the George Bensons and those…

BILL EVANS: Yeah, _Kind of Blue_ is it, that’s what I understand, yeah. It certainly
has been a strong album, and an album I was very proud to be part of.

INTERVIEWER: In fact, 20 years ago, did you think it would become such a model…important,
I mean.

BILL EVANS: No, I thought it’s really, it had to be a good record with the personnel
that was involved, and, also, I think that was perhaps the first time that Miles
had ever recorded an album where it was largely his compositions, you know. And,
there was a good feeling on the date, but I really had no idea, and I don’t think
anybody did, that it would have the influence or the duration that it did, because
you just go and you do, you know, you do your thing. But of course the people involved
were pretty gigantic when you stop and think of it. Miles and Cannonball and Coltrane
and Paul Chambers, and Jimmy Cobb, and Wynton Kelly was on one track, which is a
beautiful track, too. Like, uh, I love, I think Miles, yeah, I think Miles’ blues
solo on that track is one of my favorite solos of his. Uh, so y’know that would 
predictably make it somehow, but you can’t really tell. I don’t know what it was,
really, y’know? It just seemed to click.

INTERVIEWER: A lot has been said about the use of modes [and less?] traditional 
chord changes…

BILL EVANS: Yeah, mm-hmm. Yeah, that may have had something to do with it: just 
the fact that there were new kind of challenges to play off of, and there was a 
simplicity about the charts that was remarkable, too. Like, “Freddie the Freeloader,”“
So What” and “All Blues,” there was nothing written out on. On “So What,” I think
the introduction was written out single line, and Paul and I played it and added
a little harmony to it. Other than that, the charts were just spoken, just saying
like “play this figure,” “you play this note, you play this note.”

And I sketched out “Blue in Green,” which was my tune, and I sketched out the melody
and the changes to it for the guys, and “Flamenco Sketches” was something that Miles
and I did together that morning before the date. I went by his apartment and he 
had liked “Peace Piece” that I did and he said he’d like to do that. I thought maybe
instead of doing one ostinato, we could move through two or three or four or five
different levels that would relate to each other and make a cycle, and he agreed,
and we worked at it at the piano until we arrived at the five levels that we used.
And I wrote those levels out for the guys, you know, that was all just little sketches,
and, but other than that, it was a very simple thing that he came in with conceptually
and sketch, you know, the little sketches I made, so that a lot — all, all of it
was more or less created out of the musicians themselves, and all the things that
were added, now, like on “All Blues” you know the little fluttering figure I played
at the beginning is just something I throw in, just like, anybody will add as jazz
players to it, to a thing. But Miles had that ability to create a kind of simple
figure, like on “So What” or “All Blues,” that still generates a complete and positive
reference off of which you can play and still relate to something which is unique,
see? And so even though “All Blues” is a blues, it’s a particular kind of blues,
it has a particular kind of structure, and it’s all contained in the chart, really.

INTERVIEWER: Right. It’s like, on “All Blues” it seems like there’s certain simple
ideas that Miles uses like particularly in his chorus at the end of the piece [unintelligible?]
so simple, but so beautiful, so perfect just to have the idea to do that.

BILL EVANS: Yeah, that’s a tremendous maturity, and yeah, it is, it certainly is.
He can play just one note, a line which maybe, talking about [sings a simple rhythm:
quarter notes on the beat with a repeated pitch].

INTERVIEWER: Yeah, exactly, that’s it.

BILL EVANS: Or, there are a couple of places on “Freddie the Freeloader” where just
one note contains so much meaning that you just can hardly believe it. And that’s
what he got to, I guess, by this time. But that’s kind of a picture of the date,
and it was all done in one afternoon as far as I can remember. And the other thing
was that the first complete performance of each thing is what you’re hearing, like
the, Miles ran over the charts maybe a couple times, say “do this, do that,” and
then he laid out a structure, like you solo first or whatever. Sometimes during 
a take we wouldn’t even know that. He would walk around behind and say to you [in
a softer voice] “Take two choruses,” or “You play next.” Or, you know, whatever.
And he would lay out a thing like on “All Blues,” say like “Play the chart and then
before each soloist, the figure will serve as the little vamp, to enter into the
next soloist.” And that’s all, everybody hears and absorbs it, and once we had the
chart straight, the rest was up for grabs, and then we would play it and the first
time we’d played each thing through, that was the take that’s on the record, so 
there are no complete outtakes. So it’s kind of remarkable from that standpoint,
too, and I think maybe that accounts for some of the real freshness. ‘Cause first
take feelings are generally, if they’re anywhere near right, they’re generally the
best, and if you don’t take that one, generally you take a dip emotionally. You 
go down, and then you have to start working your way up. It’s really a professional,
laborious process of bringing yourself back up, and you can often get to a superior
take that way, but it becomes a lot of work, but if you can get that first fresh
take and it’s good enough, generally that’s a real good one. And that may account
for some of the success of this album, that all of those takes are the first takes.

INTERVIEWER: You had spoken in your liner notes about comparing those sessions to
Japanese paintings in which you have to lightly draw or else it breaks through the
parchment.

BILL EVANS: Yeah. I was comparing jazz in general, or the jazz discipline, to that
kind of thing because you can’t go back. And it’s a remarkable discipline. For people
that are considered to be the most unstable, undisciplined members of society, the
fact is that they bring to bear a kind of a discipline on their work that is practically
unparalleled. And you can’t, like if you compose, you could sit down, if you don’t
feel like it today, come back tomorrow, and after six months you might have ten 
minutes of music. But in jazz, it’s gotta be “bing” and that’s it. So, I love the
idea of it. I think it locks into a kind of a mental creative process that has implications
far beyond the people that even are doing it are aware, because the longer you do
it and the more you develop that art, the more you’re locking into a process that
is almost subconscious. It’s speaking from some levels of yourself that you’re not
even aware of. Who knows? We don’t have any idea really maybe what we’re even saying.
I think we’re part of a even perhaps an artistic and social goal as members of a
jazz tradition that we have no idea what it might be either. But I think one thing
we do know is it’s a good thing, because we intuitively committed to ourselves to
it for that reason.

INTERVIEWER: When did you first hear Miles?

BILL EVANS: Oh, I first heard Miles on the very first records he made. You know,“
Billie’s Bounce” and those things. And Miles is my favorite kind of artist. There’s
a certain kind of people that are more or less late arrivers, you can – even though
he was certainly on the scene and known and respected – you can hear him building
his abilities from the beginning very consciously and very aware of every note he
played, theoretically and motivically and everything. And it seems like those kind
of people that have to really develop more analytically and consciously and dig 
into themselves and more or less the late arrivers, they don’t have the kind of 
facility — I know Miles has spoken about how he didn’t have the facility that a 
lot of trumpet players had, and fast tempos and all this stuff, and Bird would just
tell him “Just get out there and do it,” but that kind of person, when they finally
do arrive at their own expressive level, to me, seem to contain so much more. I 
find that Tony Bennett affects me the same way as a singer. He’s a guy that has 
always worked hard to dig deeper into himself and to look into music and he respects
music a great deal and that same kind of thing happens. Now there are always a lot
of early arrivers that have great facility. And these guys say “God, he’s only 15
and listen to that young guy play, man, he’s all over the horn and he seems to have
it covered.” But often those people, and I’m saying this because maybe some people
will be listening that have those feelings, and I certainly, myself, I’m kind of
a late arriver. I knew a lot of people with those kind of facilities, and they don’t
know what to do with it often. They don’t have the ability to discard and add, and
what they really do is reflect the scene and it’s a marvelous talent that they have,
and I love to hear them play, but as real contributors and so forth they don’t add
up that much. So often the person that has to go through a more laborious, long,
digging, analytical process finally arrives at something which is much more precious.

INTERVIEWER: Art Blakey said a few months ago that Miles was a stylist.

BILL EVANS: A stylist?

INTERVIEWER: Yeah, he was describing him as that, rather than a technician.

BILL EVANS: Well, that’s a simple way to say it. I think that’s like downplaying
it a little bit. If anybody that’s a stylist, if they’re truly a stylist, if they’re
not just an eccentric. Some people try to be a stylist by being eccentric, and that’s
not really being a stylist. But Miles is truly a stylist, but that’s mainly because
he’s a strong, independent personality, and does things his own way, and always 
has, and just what we were talking about. So that is right, he is a stylist. But
that’s kind of a touchy notion.

INTERVIEWER: That “stylist” almost seems to have like a rather limiting kind of 
quality to it.

BILL EVANS: Sometimes, some of these things like, style’s an easy thing to get. 
Style’s the hardest thing to get and it’s not something you really strive for. I’m
sure that Miles never really strived to be a stylist. He just strived to be himself,
to learn, to develop, and to express a strong, independent personality. And at the
end of it, it had identity and that’s why he’s a stylist. But somebody might say,“
Wow, I could be a stylist by just reaching out and being strange,” or reaching out
and being different, or novel, and of course that’s a mistake.

INTERVIEWER: I think one thing that, in listening to the music of Miles through 
the years, that comes through, is that like technically or just as a trumpeter he
does so much, it’s not; I mean like some people relate primarily to his muted style,
and certain things that he was doing then. As he moved into the sixties, he started
to really get, more of, move away from that a little bit and just smoke, in every
sense of the word.

BILL EVANS: Technique we always think of as being a thing having to do with fastness,
too, you know, and technique is, in its highest sense, is the ability to handle 
musical materials. In that sense, Miles is one of the all-time master technicians,
in that he could play something which is an entirely original conception over something
that’s very ordinary. So, there are different ways to look at it, too. And actually,
he is virtuosic, certainly, and in the best sense of the word. You could get to 
a point where if you played any more notes it would be funny. So, I mean, how far
can you go in that direction? You understand what I’m talking about.

INTERVIEWER: Did Miles listen much other jazz or some of different styles in the
late fifties?

BILL EVANS: Miles was very much an independent person, like, I know that when I 
was hanging out with him, he liked people as different as, well he was very influenced
by Ahmad Jamal for a while. And he loved Blossom Dearie, who I love also. He would
get things from people like that he could throw into his own work, and you would
hardly know where it was coming from. And I don’t know who all he listened to, but
that’s the way he would sort of pick up things, and I don’t think; I think he certainly
did listen. He’s a guy that will turn his mind toward certain areas of music or 
certain people and decide that there’s somebody or something or an area of music
that he can learn from, and then he will. He’s very shrewd in that sense, in that
perceptive. And certainly some of his greatest talents are as a leader and as a 
person that can perceive talent and potential in people, which is proven out by 
all of the wonderful talents that have gone through his group. And I don’t think
we would have had Coltrane or known Coltrane’s potential or the great contributions
that he’s made, except for Miles and Miles’ belief in his potential. Because at 
the beginning — then, I was around when the group started — most people wondered
why Miles had Coltrane in the group. He was more or less withdrawn, plus sort of
off to the side of the bandstand, sort of half, not fumbling exactly, but just sort
of searching. And, but Miles really knew, somehow, the depth and the potential development
that Coltrane had coming, and just gave him all the room, just gave him all the 
room, man. And that’s the genius of his leadership in that he doesn’t say very much,
and he gets things done like that, he allows, puts certain talents together and 
allows them to work on each other and work on the music, and somehow Miles will 
occasionally just give you one little clue. Like he might come over to the piano
and say “Right here, I want this sound.” Now if you know music and all, you know
a lot of the implications of what that means in the total structure. That’s going
to affect other things that happen. But it turns out to be a very key thing, something
that changes the character of the whole thing. For instance, on “Green Dolphin Street,”
the vamp changes — on the original changes of course aren’t that way — the vamp 
changes would be like a major 7th up a minor third, down a half tone, down a half
tone. It’s something he leaned over and said “I want this here.” Now, of course 
that gives the total thing another character. And “Put Your Little Foot Right Out,”
which never got a lot of airplay, was on the _Jazz Track_ album with “Green Dolphin
Street.” He showed me one change on that which gave that whole structure a different
thing. Now those are two of perhaps four or five things that he ever said to me 
about [?] music, you know what I mean. [Laughs.] It wasn’t one of those things where
he’s always saying “Play this, play that, do it this way, do it that way.” But, 
that to me is a lot, a great deal of his genius. He’s not just a stylist or a great
jazz player, he’s a great leader, and he’s served a marvelous capacity to bring 
many outstanding talents out and gave them the confidence and brought them out, 
and they probably didn’t even know that Miles was doing it. I wonder sometimes whether
they really did.

INTERVIEWER: That sounds like, when we were coming over here, on the train, talking
about charisma, the notion of, I think what you said almost defines that notion,
being able to communicate like that without speaking, without telling anyone what
to do.

BILL EVANS: Yeah, it’s sort of like a magic thing. Miles is the kind of person that
if you have a conversation with him, you tend to remember every word that’s been
said. It’s true, he has a charisma. He’s a very paradoxical and many-sided person,
and if you were to take any number of things of his — acts or things he said out
of context — you could be completely on the wrong track, because he could say one
thing today and the opposite tomorrow, for reasons that have to do with momentary
response, or defense mechanisms, or who knows what. So in some ways he’s gotten 
a bad rap many times. For instance that whole thing about turning his back on the
audience and everything. I just don’t understand any of that at all. First of all,
what do you want from a creative musician? He’s up there giving you his soul and
you want him to do the acrobatics, stand on his head and what?

INTERVIEWER: There’s a film out where he plays “So What” and almost as intense as
seeing a live concert, just watching him, he’s so, he’s thinking so hard about the
solo, just watching him with the other members of the group solo.

BILL EVANS: Uh huh.

2^(nd) INTERVIEWER, EDDIE KARP: It’s really a, seeing him perform, I saw him perform
at the Bottom Line I guess was about three years ago. It was one of his last performances
with his group, before it kind of went into, before he stopped performing publicly.
And my first reaction was that this music cannot be captured on record. It seemed
like, the intensity, that he, his leadership on stage was so phenomenal, it was 
subtle but so strong, that it didn’t seem like it could be captured on record.

BILL EVANS: Yes, true. [interjecting] Well, we all feel that way. Unfortunately,
many of our best, yeah, performances are out there in the universe someplace, and
you still as professionals have to go in at ten o’clock on Wednesday and make a 
record, and hope that every few records you might catch a really good day. And the
rest of it is being professional, and certainly as professionals you do reach a 
high degree of performance in the area that you’re trying to work, but those special
times, you don’t know when they’re gonna happen, and unfortunately we don’t get 
too many of them on record.

INTERVIEWER: I was talking to agent Helen Keane the other day. She mentioned that
you had just talked to Miles.

BILL EVANS: Yeah, well, I had been talking to Philly Joe and the rumors go around.
Philly had said he heard that Miles was dying, and these things come out once in
a while. I didn’t have Miles’ number because he changes it quite frequently. And
I know that I don’t like anybody to come knocking on my door without calling, so
I hadn’t seen him in a long time for that reason. But what Philly said alarmed me,
so Philly says, “I’ll meet you over there.” I said, “Great.” So I went over there
expecting Joe to be there already, but Joe hadn’t arrived, and didn’t during the
time I was visiting. But I rang the bell and it was alright because Miles was up
and was glad to hear from me, and Gil was there that day, and he just looked great
and seemed in great spirits. So it was all just rumor. But he seemed to feel that
he wasn’t ready to come out and play, even though I somewhat prevailed upon him 
that the world was waiting for him and he didn’t seem to have the inclination to
come out and play. But I understand that Gil and he are involved in some kind of
a project now to record, or to record and tour, or something. Now, whether or not
it will happen, I don’t know.

INTERVIEWER: I was told on Tuesday, just a rumor that’s flying around, that Miles
was in a studio.

BILL EVANS: Well, that’s what I’ve been hearing too, and I think it may be true 
because, first of all, I don’t; Miles is a player and I can’t imagine him not playing.
I mean, this may be just a long break, for what reason, I don’t know. He may want
to come back with something entirely new or entirely old, as far as I know. But 
I can’t imagine him not playing ‘cause I think that his soul is fed by playing and
it may be that he was feeling a little unsatisfied in his soul with what was happening
at some point or whatever; I don’t know what his reasons are, but I’m sure he’ll
be back.

INTERVIEWER: Did he tell you any times about what he was looking for in his music,
especially maybe in the late sixties when he was…

BILL EVANS: No, we never talked about things like that, and I don’t think Miles 
talks about things like that with anybody. I think you just have to perceive it 
from what he’s playing and what he’s feeling and sense and know kind of where it’s
at somehow. I think it’s all in the music anyhow. I think there was a point, in 
my own opinion, where he made a turn, reaching for a large audience, I don’t know,
or what, with the bands, and I have often wanted to speak to Miles about that period
and find out how he felt about it, what he thought he possibly had developed or 
learned or whether that was a direction he’d like to go farther in or what. And 
he might talk to me about that kind of thing, but I’ve been curious about it because
I didn’t completely sympathize with some of the music he got into. But anyhow, that’s,
you can’t second-guess Miles. He’s always gonna surprise you and then prove himself
right in the long run.

INTERVIEWER: Well, we know you’re in a hurry, and we’ve been here and it’s been 
a really fascinating, great conversation. I’ve really enjoyed it, and we’ve been
talking to Bill Evans and before we let you off, is there anything else you’d like
to say about Miles or any [?] of the unbelievable [?] in his career that [?]?

BILL EVANS: Well, I often have said this, but I’ll say it again, that the most beneficial
thing that happened to me in that association was that it confirmed my own identity
to myself at a time when it would have been easy for me to go in certain directions
that attracted a lot of critical and public attention, like sort of avant garde,
and I was, at that time, more or less, in the avant garde, and could function in
Third Stream and avant garde, and the kind of attention you got sometimes could 
almost turn your head and you start perhaps thinking, well, maybe this is the direction,
but being with the band and the real honest personalities involved really helped
confirm my own identity, and made me realize that being myself was the only place
to be. That’s about it.

INTERVIEWER: OK, well, thank you very much. [?]

[?] the scene and a lot of new information and really.

**About this interview and recording:**

As far as I know, this interview has been rarely heard since it was broadcast on
WKCR on July 4, 1979 and it seems not to be available online until now. Dr. Greg
Smith has his own copy, probably taped off the air by someone else, and he played
it for the graduate musicology seminars on Bill Evans (the subject of his Harvard
PhD dissertation) that he taught at New England Conservatory. Ashley Kahn, author
of an authoritative and enjoyable book on _Kind of Blue_, quotes from the interview
and, I believe, draws conclusions in his book from it (at least partly). He may 
have heard it in the WKCR archives. And I put a CD-R of it on reserve at the NEC
library for my own Jazz Styles classes to listen to in a few semesters between 1997
and 2008.

The provenance of this recording is an interesting jazz history footnote in itself.
In the summer of 1979, my good friend from Phoenix, the great drummer Lewis Nash(
then 20 years old) was staying with the family of a friend of his in Bronxville 
NY, and studying with Freddie Waits, Billy Hart, and Andrew Cyrille, and hearing
as much music as possible. I was living in Philadelphia, starting a PhD program 
at Penn in Music History and Theory that I soon decided was not for me. We were 
both living away from Phoenix for the first time as adults, and I took the train
to NYC as much as I could to hear music. We heard Jimmy Cobb on one amazing evening
at the Tin Palace (a double bill of Dewey Redman’s and Clifford Jordan’s quartets)
and Philly Joe Jones there on another night. Lewis was excited about hearing as 
much as possible of the 126-hour Miles Davis Festival on WKCR and recorded three
interviews on his portable cassette recorder placed near a clock radio in the bedroom
where he was staying, if I recall correctly.

When we were both back in Phoenix and playing as a duo that fall, Lewis made me 
a copy of the two cassettes, one with the Bill Evans and Jimmy Cobb interviews, 
and one with two sides of Lester Bowie. We both listened to these interviews so 
much that we memorized them. (Lester Bowie’s was like a favorite comedy record —
hilarious as well as insightful. The audio is below.) I still have the cassettes
and I digitized them when I got a CD burner and was teaching jazz history at NEC.

For years, I wasn’t sure about whose recordings these were and how to respond to
many requests to share them. Ashley Kahn told me the interviewer was Bill Goldberg
and that he was an MD in the Boston area. I found him through Facebook; he told 
me he recorded the interview himself, away from WKCR, and gave me written permission
to share it. He didn’t have a copy, so I sent him a CD-R of it. So, I’m sharing 
it here.

**\*\*About the composer credit for “Blue in Green:”** Bill Evans said more than
once that he wrote it at Miles’ request based on two chords suggested by Miles (
quoted as G minor to A augmented). Aural evidence and Bill’s solo piano intro on
Chet Baker’s _Chet_ album track “Alone Together” (prior to _Kind of Blue_) tend 
to support Bill Evans’ role. Miles didn’t challenge Bill Evans’s composer credit
for the tune on _Portrait in Jazz_and later recordings of the tune, as far as we
know. I have a note saying “they may have argued about it once,” but I don’t recall
the source — probably hearsay from someone with secondhand knowledge. I haven’t 
heard the studio chatter, but I’ve been told it’s Miles giving the instructions 
on the tune in the studio. (Is this specifically about the changing harmonic rhythm,
double and quadruple time? Is this studio chatter audible on 50th Anniversary Legacy
Edition multi-disc set? **[UPDATE 5.18.19**: I first heard the 50th Anniversary 
CD set after writing this. The only commentary I can hear regarding the form and
harmonic rhythm of “Blue in Green” is given by Bill Evans. Bonus track 12 on CD 
1 seems to capture him in the middle of instructing the band. Evans’ words “long
meter” are audible — the only thing I can hear clearly on the subject.**]**) Bill
Evans used the three levels of harmonic rhythm in his own later performances, too(
_Portrait in Jazz_ takes 2 and 3; _Blue in Green_ live 8/74 version). If the melody
of “Blue in Green” is taken to be the line that Bill Evans plays in the first chorus
on _Portrait in Jazz_, then it appears most clearly in the final piano statement
on _Kind of Blue_, and Miles’ first theme statement is related but not very literal:
some notes left out, some changed, some added. It could be an interpretation of 
Bill’s written melody, if there was a written melody; Miles played some standards
about this abstractly in that period. On the other hand, it’s possible the theme
was just a suggestion at the time of _Kind of Blue_, Miles improvising after hearing
Bill run through the tune. That seems (almost) equally plausible to me. **[UPDATE**:
Miles plays the first few bars more literally on the false start, adding to the 
likelihood that he may have been reading the melody.**]**

Miles may have said once in an interview that it was Bill Evans’ tune. _Miles: The
Autobiography_ says Miles claims everything on _Kind of Blue_ is his, not a collaboration
with Bill Evans. (However,  _Miles: The Autobiography _is notoriously unreliable;
someone would have to check the interview tapes for Miles’ exact words, if this 
is drawn from his words — Miles said he never wrote nor _read_ the book.)

The Miles Davis official website, as of 2012, implied credit to Bill Evans, but 
the words there are lacking in musical and historical accuracy and/or clarity, e.
g. “He also borrowed from Bill Evans, the principal creator of this album, the kind
of blue that is reflected in ‘Blue In Green.’” The principal creator of this album?
That absurdly overstates even the most generous accounts of Bill Evans’ role, including
his own account in this interview.

The Harry Fox Agency Songfile, used for research on mechanical royalties, lists “
Blue in Green” by Miles Davis (as of 2012), not by Bill Evans.

![Image result for Bill Evans on Miles Davis and Kind of Blue](https://i0.wp.com/
www.sfjazz.org/globalassets/discover/blog/blog-images/kindofblue_session.jpg?w=640&
ssl=1)

### _Related_