# The Bad Plus: Stravinsky, Ligeti, and Babbitt … Videos, Photos

- Link: https://jazzblues.eu/2020/08/26/the-bad-plus-stravinsky-ligeti-and-babbitt-videos-photos/
- Published: 2020-08-26T00:01:33+01:00
- Author: https://JazzBlues.EU

**(When Keane Southard contacted me about writing a paper on the “classical” tracks
on For All I Care, I admit I was a little suspicious, for at the time it felt like
what we did mostly flew over the heads of everybody. However, Keane was serious 
about the sounds and I ended up being flattered by his attention. The paper was 
submitted as “Modernist Classical Music on The Bad Plus’s For All I Care” for the
Eastman course, Jazz and Classical Interactions.**

More recently I enjoyed listening to the first movement of Keane’s Symphony No. 
2 performed by American Composer’s Orchestra.

Most of my quotes below are from a phone call in early 2019 or the 2009 JazzTimes
article, “Crossing Streams,” which was my formal attempt to explain TBP’s intentions
to a jazz audience.

![](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2020/08/solo0309.jpg?w=640)

I have cleaned up a few of my quotes and added a few more pieces of historical content.
The original paper, which includes more specific timings and details about events
within each track. Keane’s comments are on the money and I remain proud of this 
music. — E.I. )

![](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2020/08/for-all-i-care.jpg?w=
640)

The Bad Plus released For All I Care in 2009.  In addition to being their first 
album with a collaborator, singer Wendy Lewis, the album was the group’s first foray
into “classical music,” namely modernist works by the intrepid twentieth-century
composers Igor Stravinsky, György Ligeti, and Milton Babbitt.

Within the band, pianist Ethan Iverson had studied European classical music privately
and spent five years performing in the idiom with the Mark Morris Dance Group. Bassist
Reid Anderson got a degree in performance from the renowned Curtis Institute of 
Music. Drummer David King worked with Minneapolis offshoots of Bang on a Can; it
was also King’s idea to contextualize the Wendy Lewis pop covers with trio covers
of modernist classical music on For All I Care.

In his teaching and in his writings online, Iverson argues jazz has always intersected
with European classical music. “The older I get and the more research that I do,
the more convinced I am that jazz cats always knew European classical music.  It’s
actually the separation of the genres that can lead to problems: I like to joke 
with my students that there’s no such thing as jazz harmony. Anyway, as I say, Jelly
Roll Morton knew European classical music, Sonny Clark knew it.  Whoever you think
is especially soulful and pure in a jazz or blues idiom, the odds are that they 
spent at least some time in that world.”

There’s a certain tradition of “jazzing the classics,” but usually that means lightly
swinging renditions of familiar melodies by composers like Chopin and Rachmaninoff.
Modernist classical music presents unique challenges for those who want to play 
it in a jazz context.

In a 2009 article for JazzTimes about For All I Care, “Crossing Streams” (the title
alludes to Gunther Schuller’s idea of Third Stream), Iverson describes two primary
issues, “How do you fit real, grooving drumming into the context of harmonically
advanced and rhythmically disjunct modern classical music?” and “How do you bridge
the gulf harmonically between really modernist classical music and what a normal
jazz musician can improvise?”  While calling Dave Douglas’s Stravinsky and Webern
performances “excellent” and Richie Beirach’s Bartók recordings “successful,” he
laments that these jazz versions are “almost never with grooving drums.  And without
drums, would a jazz musician really want to play it every day?”  With the three 
classical works on For All I Care, The Bad Plus sought ways to overcome these two
obstacles.  Iverson speculated that, “Maybe if we added real drums and were careful
about how much we improvised we could make them work.”

Milton Babbitt, known as a modernist composer of uncompromisingly complex serial
and electronic music, may seem to many to be one of the least likely classical composers
to find one of his works placed in a jazz context, but Babbitt has more connections
to jazz than most people realize.  (Few know that he also flirted with a career 
as a popular songwriter, but as Jerome Kuderna, who wrote a dissertation on Babbitt’s
piano works, points out “the unpopular serious composer won out over the unserious
popular one.”)  In 1957, he composed All Set, that, while created using complex 
and rigid systems for organizing both pitch and rhythm, was written for small jazz
ensemble and, according to the composer, has, “jazz-like properties…the use of percussion,
the Chicago jazz-like juxtapositions of solos and ensembles recalling certain characteristics
of group improvisation.”  Additionally, nearly half a century later in 2002, he 
wrote A Gloss on ‘Round Midnight for piano based on Thelonious Monk’s jazz standard.

Iverson was introduced Babbitt’s relatively easy solo piano work Semi-Simple Variations
by Patrick Zimmerli, a jazz saxophonist who loves modern classical music and with
whom Iverson became friends with in the early 1990s.  In addition to playing the
work in a recital at New York University where Iverson was a student, Zimmerli and
Iverson played it as their “sign-off theme” whenever they played a duo gig together.
In 2008, Iverson decided to perform Babbitt’s piece for the release party for Alex
Ross’s book The Rest is Noise: Listening to the Twentieth Century. One day Dave 
King started playing drums with it while Iverson practiced at soundcheck.  “It actually
sounded-surprisingly-not so bad.  Twelve-tone funk?…Reid Anderson joined us and 
we played it some more.  With bass added, it seemed totally legit.”  (Interestingly,
Kuderna’s 1982 dissertation actually noted the piece’s rhythms as being “so jazzy
and syncopated that one would never suspect that they were subjected to the same
minute control as the pitch aggregates,” this more than twenty-five years before
The Bad Plus’s discovery of them.)

When comparing Babbitt’s original work to the Bad Plus’s recordings, the most obvious
difference is the addition of double bass and drum set.  I’ll look first at the 
longer of the two versions of the work included on the album, before considering
the “alternate version” of the work.

The pianist plays the notes and rhythms of Babbitt’s work more or less exactly as
written, while the bass doubles the melody during the theme and first variation 
before mostly doubling the lowest note of the left hand of the piano for the rest
of the piece.  Being comprised solely of instruments of indefinite pitch, the drum
set part is the only part of the trio not playing Babbitt’s written notes.  While
the complex drum part is apparently improvised, as evidenced by a noticeably varied
part in the “alternate version,” it is used to help find the groove in the piece
and to clarify its formal structure.  At the beginning, King constantly changes 
and shifts his groove in order to accent and highlight different “hits” in the piece.
The energy gathers for the last two variations and King plays more like a backbeat.

A forty-second improvisation follows before the group repeats the final two variations(
IV and V) and then the theme and first variation before finally ending.

**Form of Milton Babbitt’s Semi-Simple Variations performed by The Bad Plus on For
All I Care**

  |  **Section** |  Whole piece (Theme, Var I-V) |  Improvisation |  Repeat of Var. IV and V |  Repeat of Theme and Var. I |  
 |  **Duration** |  1’07” |  40” |  20” |  20” |

Iverson has mixed feelings about the improvisation.  In the JazzTimes article, he
states that “on the longer version [of Semi-Simple Variations] we broke down and
improvised a little bit,” adding that “it sounds good, but sadly it is not in the
12-tone language.” (Iverson also added that “someday there will be musicians comfortable
improvising together in the pure 12-tone language,” and indeed four years later 
saxophonist John O’Gallagher published Twelve-Tone Improvisation (A Method for Using
Twelve Tone Rows in Jazz). Ten years later in my own interview with him, despite
admitting that he may not have even heard the track since recording, he said he 
was “not satisfied with it.”  He mentions that they “were just playing by ear and
trying to sound like the style” without any planning beforehand.  While on tour,
the improvised section was soon dropped, and Iverson says, “I’m sure I was the one
that put my foot down about that. There is something about blowing on Babbitt that’s
fundamentally cheesy.  It doesn’t need to be done.”

Iverson’s improvisation begins by playing three-note clusters built with half-steps
and, while not twelve-tone or serial, maintains a very dissonant atonal style throughout.
Unlike the discontinuity of Babbitt, the improvisors work with obvious motives; 
they nearly vamp before a drum fill leads us back into Babbitt’s work as written.

Babbitt’s score is filled with specific and quick dynamic changes, having up to 
three different dynamic markings in the space of two beats, yet the trio’s recording
completely ignores any changes in dynamics. Iverson explains, “The dynamics don’t‘
pop’ when you play Semi-Simple with drums…The minute Dave King was playing the drums
with it, I pretty much ignored the dynamics. This disappointed Gunther Schuller 
when he heard us play Semi-Simple at the Regattabar.”

The Bad Plus’s recording of this work adheres very strictly to Babbitt’s metronome
marking of quarter-note=84 for the entire work.  By keeping this tempo strict, they
were able to find a groove hiding within the piece which I haven’t found in any 
of available conventional recordings of the work, which all take liberties with 
speeding up and slowing the tempo.  A solo pianist who doesn’t have to stay together
with other players is more apt to vary the tempo and thus can choose to downplay
the groove of the piece (if they even can find it). Iverson says: “The only other
Babbitt I know that is as square rhythmically as Semi-Simple is Three Compositions
for Piano. Usually Babbitt’s rhythms are as disjunct as his pitches and dynamics.
Since Semi-Simple is only sixteenths, there was an amusing opportunity to ‘rock 
out.’”

The other recording of Semi-Simple Variations on the album is listed as the “alternate
version” which features no adjustments to Babbitt’s formal design—the trio begins
at the beginning of the piece and ends at the end.

The piano and bass parts are essentially identical to the full play-through in the
other recording, while King’s drum part is slightly varied while maintaining the
same essential features. The only other noticeable difference is a post-production
addition of a scratchy needle-on-vinyl sound at the beginning that then acts as 
a filter that fades in and out changing the timbre of the music over the course 
of the track, which was added by producer Tchad Blake.

**György Ligeti Fém (Etude No. 8)**

The Bad Plus’s recording of Ligeti’s Fém (Etude No. 8), which Iverson describes 
as a combination of “the maniacal excess of Conlon Nancarrow and the rhythmic folklore
of the Pygmies,” is treated in a similar way to the Babbitt. Here we also have a
work originally for solo piano where Iverson plays the notes and rhythms as Ligeti
wrote, Anderson doubles the lowest sounding pitches of the pianist’s left hand at
pitch or at some number of octaves lower, and King creates his own drum part.

Iverson describes their version as a “drum feature” and points out that the rhythms
come from African music.  Indeed, in her dissertation on Ligeti’s music, Amy Marie
Bauer states that this etude’s rhythms, “model those of sub-Saharan African polyphony.”
Perhaps it is this influence from African music which makes the piece susceptible
to jazz treatment, or at least the adding of a drum part to it.  Ligeti himself 
amusingly suggests this connection by asking the player to play “mit ‘swing’” (“
with swing”) in the performance notes in the score.  Ligeti also writes that, while
he gives the meter as 12/8, that “(Eine Taktmetrik existiert nicht, die Taktstriche
dienen nur zur Synchronisierung)” “(There is no real metre here; the bar lines are
only to help synchronisation.)”

Iverson says, “When great classical pianists play this piece, I think they hear 
it as a ground pulse of six to a bar, but our little secret was hearing it as four
to a bar. If you are talking about ‘mit ‘swing,’’ if you’re going to swing out on
it, you’ve got to play four to a bar, not six.”

Like the longer recording of the Babbitt, the group makes some significant changes
to the form of the piece.  As this arrangement was designed to be a drum feature,
the recording begins with a four-bar drum introduction, and the flow of the piece
is interrupted by periodic drum breaks. The band also leaves out the soft and slower
coda.

**Form of György Ligeti’s Fém (Etude No. 8)** **performed by The Bad Plus on For
All I Care, **

  |  **Section** |  Drum Intro |  m. 1-12 |  Drum break |  m. 1-12 |  Drum break |  m. 13-24 |  Drum break |  m. 13-24 |  Drum break |  m. 25-57 |  
 |  **# of ** **measures** |  4 |  12 |  4 |  12 |  4 |  12 |  4 |  12 |  4 |  33 |

Iverson explains the decision to exclude the coda: “Because we’re highlighting the
drums in the composition, a little feature for Dave, the coda becomes extraneous.”
This allows the piece to end on a literal high note and at its loudest dynamic marking(
FFFF with a crescendo to “tutta la forza”) like several other of his Études, such
as No. 14 “Columna infinita.”

The early ending is also heralded by added repetitions of the penultimate chord.

**Comparison of György Ligeti’s Fém (Etude No. 8) m. 57 with “m. 57” of The Bad 
Plus’s recording of the work (drum part omitted)**

 

![](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2020/08/ligeti-m.-57-comparison_0001.
jpg?w=640)

 

When Iverson has played the piece as a solo work (as he did on The Rest is Noise
tour with Alex Ross) he includes the coda as originally written.

Notably, there is no improvising in the piano and bass, as Iverson notes that “Reid
and I have too much respect for the authenticity of Ligeti’s sophisticated atonal
harmonic language to improvise on it.” While Iverson suggested the decision to include
drum breaks was simple by saying, “It’s a drum feature, let’s have some drum breaks,”
the insertion of them also helps to clarify the formal structure of Ligeti’s work,
much like how the drums functioned in the Babbitt recordings.

This also helps to explain the trio’s approach to Ligeti’s dynamic markings in the
score.  While the trio ignored Babbitt’s dynamic markings, they roughly follow Ligeti’s,
for Ligeti’s use of dynamic changes help give each section more dramatic contrast.

**Igor Stravinsky’s “Variation d’Apollon”**

Compared to the Babbitt or Ligeti, the trio’s rendition of Stravinsky’s “Variation
d’Apollon,” a movement from his 1928 ballet Apollon Musagète is freer and more relaxed.
The group treats Stravinsky’s score more like a jazz player might use a song by 
George Gershwin, using the harmonies and melody as a guideline, much like a jazz
lead sheet instead of a strict set of notes and rhythms to follow in the classical
tradition. The piano and bass alter the pitches and rhythms as well as changes to
the formal structure.

While the Babbitt and Ligeti pieces were from Iverson’s library, “Variation d’Apollon”
was an Anderson discovery. (For a time in the mid-’90s, it was the music on Anderson’s
answering machine.) Apollo is scored for string orchestra, but the group’s arrangement
is based on the piano reduction that Stravinsky himself created for the ballet’s
rehearsals.

After playing the whole movement through once, they elide the downbeat of the final
measure’s arrival on an A major chord with a restart from the beginning but now 
down a minor sixth. Iverson jokes, “We put a little Beethoven modulation in there.”

After what is almost a conventional improvisation in the new key, the music builds
and goes back to F major halfway through the “second chorus.” The shift back to 
the original pitch level is made fairly smooth by the fact that the bass line maintains
a stepwise motion.

**Comparison of Igor Stravinsky’s “Variation d’Apollon” (piano version) Third to
Fifth measure after rehearsal 60, compared with The Bad Plus’s recording with expanded
modulation in the “second chorus” from A to F major**

 

![](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2020/08/bad-plus-stravinsky-key-
adjustment_0002.jpg?w=640)

From that point on, the score is once again followed reasonably accurately until
the end, where the band adds a “tag” on to the form.

**Comparison of Igor Stravinsky’s“Variation d’Apollon” (piano version) last two 
measures compared with of The Bad Plus’s recording of the work (drum part omitted)**

 

![](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2020/08/bad-plus-stravinsky-ending-
original_0001.jpg?w=1024&resize=401%2C191)

 

![](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2020/08/bad-plus-stravinsky-ending-
tbp_0001.jpg?w=640)

Iverson’s playing does not adhere as strictly to the notes and rhythms written as
in the other two works, but instead plays the piece more like one would a traditional
jazz standard while also echoing the Baroque keyboard practice of improvising and
adding spontaneous ornamentation. During the first play-through, he focuses on playing
the melody while providing a chordal accompaniment underneath it, leaving most of
the bass line to Anderson and only doubling it occasionally.  While he does include
some of Stravinsky’s counterpoint and inner voice melodies, he ignores most of it
while keeping the melody as written.  In general, Anderson’s bass line takes more
liberties than Iverson’s melody, playing roughly half of Stravinsky’s written bass
line while embellishing and improvising on the other half.  King’s drums are generally
soft, often using brushes, and played in a “homemade electronica” style that he 
employed in the group’s recording of Flim by Aphex Twin.

In describing how The Bad Plus creates their own versions of pop and rock songs,
bassist Reid Anderson says that, “We definitely don’t try to put it in a jazz framework.
Anything that we do, we just try to take it on its own terms, however it seems to
us.”  Yet drummer Dave King explains the connection to jazz in their approach to
these songs by saying, “We take music on which we can improvise and reharmonize 
and use all the tools that jazz musicians have always used, and try to turn it into
something that sounds like we own it.”  But in their “interpretations with drum 
set,” as King puts it, of modernist classical works of Babbitt, Ligeti, and Stravinsky
on For All I Care, the group employs very little improvisation and virtually no 
reharmonization.

The recordings of both Babbitt’s Semi-Simple Variations and Ligeti’s Fém (Etude 
No. 8) feature the pianist playing the pitches and rhythms of these piano works 
almost exactly as notated in the score.  In addition, the bass doubles a melodic
line, most often the bass line, an improvised drum part is added, and the formal
structure is modified in addition to several other minor changes.  Even though the
longer version of the Babbitt includes a freely improvised section, Iverson is not
sure it was successful, and they soon dropped the idea from their live performances.
For Stravinsky’s “Variation d’Apollon,” they treat the score in a freer way, viewing
it more like a lead sheet, partially recomposing it, extending the form, and often
embellishing the melody and bass line while ignoring the other contrapuntal lines.

Despite recomposing part of the Stravinsky, the group displays a tendency to not
alter these works too much, as they clearly revere these pieces and did not want
their treatment of them to come across as ironic or mocking.  As Iverson states,“
We love the melody of Stravinsky’s ‘Variation d’Apollo’ so much that we wanted to
play it twice as long as the original.  And why bother improvising when there is
already such supreme beauty to enjoy?”  King adds that, “We’re actually quite earnest
about everything we’re trying to take apart,” but he states that at the same time
they are trying to assert their own group’s identity and figure out, “How do we 
take this non-ironic stance and make [the music] our own?”^( )

“Jazzing” classical music has been a practice since the early days of jazz, but 
the biggest problems with performing modernist classical works in a jazz context
are how to include grooving drums that don’t sound out of place and how to bridge
the harmonic gap between the compositions and what jazz players can improvise.  
As Iverson points out, to solve the first of these problems, they had to, “Find 
material that Dave King can play and that pretty much solves the rest of it.”  For
the second problem, they solved it by having the bass and piano essentially play
the notes and rhythms of the compositions as written while keeping improvisation
to a minimum.  While the drum parts are all improvised, they are all instruments
of indefinite pitch and therefore bypass the issue of harmony altogether.  These
two aspects, the grooving drums and the pitched instruments playing the pieces pretty
much as written, may be what is most unique about these recordings.  Iverson says
this is probably “the first time where the pianist sat and played professional level
modernist discontinuous classical music accurately from a score and those other 
parts were then added to it.  That was probably relatively unprecedented.”

There is one big question still lingering that I haven’t yet addressed: are these
renditions really jazz?  As mentioned above, these recordings largely forego the
typical jazz practices of improvising and reharmonizing, yet they use several other“
tools that jazz musicians have always used” to create strong connections with the
jazz tradition, including the instrumentation of a standard jazz trio, a complex
improvised drum part that is based around a groove, treating Stravinsky’s score 
like a lead sheet, and making significant alterations to the form of the original
work.  Yet, determining whether these renditions are truly jazz or not is a question
I’m not going to attempt to answer here, but it is something The Bad Plus have been
asked about frequently.

![](https://ethaniversondotcom.files.wordpress.com/2020/08/tbp-rite.jpg?w=640)

A few years after For All I Care, the group went even further into the modernist
classical world by creating and performing a complete version of Stravinsky’s seminal
Rite of Spring, for which they approached the piece in a very similar way as they
did the Babbitt and Ligeti.  Iverson explains, “It was essentially the same thing:
mostly playing it straight in the piano but a couple tiny structural things here
and there, add a repeat sign or something like that, stuff that is obvious and makes
sense, then to figure out a way to integrate the drums.”

Iverson continues, “I’m not really sure this is a jazz version either.  Lots of 
stuff in TBP walks the line: ‘Is this jazz?’ Well, the TBP/Rite is on a whole other
avenue.  Hey, if you want to call it jazz, great.  We certainly love jazz!  But 
for me, the phrase ‘a jazz version of ‘The Rite’’ sits there wilting on the vine…
I’m already yawning.  We are trusting that TBP fans understand that we bring TBP
to the room in whatever we do.  Imagine if I played jazz chords in our cover of 
Aphex Twin’s ‘Flim,’ wouldn’t that be awful?

But whatever style, genre, or category one might place these renditions in, I would
certainly be the first to say that, above all, they are great music.

![The Bad Plus presents a 'sonically different' Stravinsky | Music |  stltoday.com](
https://i0.wp.com/bloximages.newyork1.vip.townnews.com/stltoday.com/content/tncms/
assets/v3/editorial/2/27/2274213a-3336-5fe2-a857-dae732a95a13/5243387fbe1ed.preview-
1024.jpg?w=640&ssl=1)

### _Related_
