# Compare and you։ Max Roach, “Members Don’t Git Weary,” Gary Bartz, “Another Earth,” and Charles Tolliver, “Paper Man”: Videos, Photos

- Link: https://jazzblues.eu/2022/11/27/compare-and-you%d6%89-max-roach-members-dont-git-weary-gary-bartz-another-earth-and-charles-tolliver-paper-man-videos-photos/
- Published: 2022-11-27T00:02:19+01:00
- Author: https://JazzBlues.EU

**Summer 1968. Three killer LPs made in the space of two weeks document one version
of serious and community-focused black jazz. In the larger frame, it was the Aquarian
age, a time of youthful rebellion and the expansion of consciousness. **

The Civil Rights movement had scored major victories, but there was still a long
way to go (Martin Luther King was assassinated in April). In the musical realm John
Coltrane had died less than a year earlier, around the time Miles Davis released
_Nefertiti_, the final Davis album without electric instruments. Black-owned Motown
had established serious market share on the radio, and any kind of avant-garde technique
borrowed from free jazz was also on the table.

Present on all three sessions was a pair of upcoming and outstanding horn players,
Charles Tolliver and Gary Bartz. Max Roach’s _Members Don’t Git Weary_ feature them
both; Tolliver guests on half of Bartz’s _Another Earth_; Bartz guests on half of
Tolliver’s _Paper Man_. (In the liner notes to _Another Earth,_ Maxine Bartz says
that the Bartz/Tolliver association goes back to 1959.)

According to obvious sources, these are the dates and places for the 1968 sessions:

**Bartz, _Another Earth_** (Milestone), June 19 & 25, Plaza Sound Studios, NYC
 **
Roach,_ Members, Don’t Git Weary_** (Atlantic), June 25 & 26, RCA Studio B, NYC **
Tolliver, _Paper Man_** (Black Lion), July 2, Town Sound Studios, Englewood, NJ

June 25 is listed for both Roach and Bartz, which is unlikely, especially since 
they are different labels and studios, but not absolutely impossible. (The recording
dates for the sessions are present in the original liner notes for Bartz and Tolliver,
but not for Roach. Roach is found online and in the Lord discography. Possibly a
user error entered the system at some point.)

**Max Roach, _Members, Don’t Git Weary _with Charles Tolliver, Gary Bartz, Stanley
Cowell, Jymie Merritt, and vocalist Andy Bey on the title track**

Max Roach was one of the original bebop geniuses in the group that included Charlie
Parker, Dizzy Gillespie, Bud Powell, and Thelonious Monk. In the ’50’s he co-led
one of the great ensembles of all time with Clifford Brown; in the ’60s Roach was
a visible advocate for Civil Rights, with albums called _We Insist!_ and _Speak,
Brother, Speak!_

Roach knew the whole history of the music, recording successfully with everyone 
from Duke Ellington to Cecil Taylor. The style of _Members, Don’t Git Weary_ is 
absolutely of the moment, with little in the way of the pure bebop tradition of 
Roach’s earlier associates Bud Powell or Charlie Parker. Instead there are funk 
beats, electric bass vamps, and modal tropes straight from John Coltrane and McCoy
Tyner.

**“Abstrutions”** Stanley Cowell supplies three pieces for the date. The main funky
riff of “Abstrutions” is answered by a quartal phrase reminiscent of Eddie Harris’s“
Freedom Jazz Dance.” Cowell is the only soloist, displaying greasy two-handed pianism
with the horns giving responses. A radio-friendly track.

**“Libra” **Gary Bartz debuted this memorable modal theme on his first album,_ Libra_,
recorded the previous year. Staccato rhythmic hits give away to fast 4/4 for hard
blowing from Bartz and Tolliver. Great drum solo, Roach’s kit is well-recorded. 
This is the one tune where Merritt walks, and I admit that this is the only place
it might have been better if he had been playing upright instead of electric bass.

**“Effi”** Roach gets credit for playing the first jazz waltzes on record in the’
50s. By this point his conception was quite loose and fluid, perhaps even influenced
by the way Elvin Jones played “My Favorite Things.” Cowell’s piece moves around 
a bit harmonically, but the horn trades make the most of the related pentatonic 
scale.

**“Equipoise”** Probably Cowell’s best-known composition. The first recording is
a masterpiece, an evocative way to turn the modal burn into an impressionistic even-
eighths tone poem. Both Tolliver and Bartz show their lyrical side. Again, while
the chord sequence is quite complex, the soloists are able to access pentatonic 
scales common to disparate bass notes/harmonies.

![Happy 95th Birthday to Max Roach | In The Muse: Performing Arts Blog](https://
i0.wp.com/blogs.loc.gov/music/files/2019/01/max-and-count-1024x682.jpg?resize=640%
2C426&ssl=1)

**“Members, Don’t Git Weary”** While credited to Roach, “Members, Don’t Git Weary”
is an older spiritual. The band plays in a loose rubato style, as on the opening
part of of Coltrane’s “Spiritual.” Andy Bey sounds great leading the congregation.

**“Absolutions”** Jymie Merritt was a bassist associated with both Art Blakey and
Max Roach. He wrote a few important pieces; the best-known is probably “Nommo,” 
an early excursion into 7/4 recorded by both Roach and Lee Morgan. “Absolutions”
is a dark investigation of the Phrygian mode with an ominous 4/4 bass line. Cowell
is on electric piano and Roach delivers many fierce single-stroke rolls next to 
Merritt’s vamp. The horns play their angular modal phrases that hew reasonably close
to the dark keyboard tonality. Overall, the aesthetic of “Absolutions” is absolutely
next door to the 1968 Miles Davis sessions that produced _Miles in the Sky_ and 
_Filles de Kilimanjaro_, especially the similar in-your-face even-eighth drumming
of Max Roach and Tony Williams. Fabulous.

The only serious problem with _Members, Don’t Get Weary _is the lack of piano solos,
for Cowell only lets loose on the opening track.

![Best Max Roach Pieces: Essentials From A Jazz Icon](https://i0.wp.com/www.udiscovermusic.
com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Max-Roach-GettyImages-90954599.jpg?w=640&ssl=1)

**Gary Bartz, _Another Earth_ with Stanley Cowell, Reggie Workman, and Freddie Waits,
joined by Charles Tolliver and Pharoah Sanders on the title suite**

While Bird was the bebop word, Trane gave the modal message. In 1968, compared to
the tenor sax roster, the altos were less thick on the ground. Ornette Coleman and
Eric Dolphy had established the avant-garde model, taken up in varied ways by people
like James Spaulding, Marion Brown, Jimmy Lyons and Ken McIntyre, but there was 
plenty of room for Gary Bartz to present the swinging and burning Trane concept 
on alto. (Sonny Fortune was Bartz’s peer, but he wasn’t so apparent on record yet.)

**“Another Earth”** This side-long suite is genuinely successful, a kind of updating
of Coltrane’s long-form concept for _Meditations_ and other pieces, but with more
written material and more stylistic diversity. (In addition, the theme of planets
in the cosmos recalls Coltrane’s_ Interstellar Space_.) Compositionally there’s 
a lot here, but in the end it is also very much a feature for the leader’s incandescent
alto.

1) Fanfare with intervallic theme. 2) Intervallic theme becomes gospel with preaching
alto solo. 3) Minor swing that almost immediately devolves into late Trane style
with Sanders in full effect, followed by Bartz also in high-expressionistic mood,
who brings in the time with 4) New uptempo theme, minor modal with a few dominant
chord changes. Tolliver and Bartz both blow well over a loose rhythm section. 5)
Bass cadenza. 6) “Wall of sound” chords from all hands with alto cadenzas. 7) A 
brief syncopated passage turns into a dirge, a hint of waltz, a hard unison flourish,
then back to 8) Medium swing with Tolliver telling his story with that beautiful
trumpet sonority. More joyous Bartz, before Sanders steps up to play a bit of swinging
tenor before going more into the esoteric zone. Sounds great. Cowell finally gets
a bit of a say, with a relaxed searching exploration in tempo, both hands in different
places.  9) A few horn lines and concluding fanfare.

All told, “Another Earth” must be one of the very best long-form suites from this
era and context. Freddie Waits is the true MVP, handling all the changes of mood
with depth and finesse.

**“Dark Nebula” **The swinging piece alternates between 3/4 and 4/4. Workman may
have been considered a straight-ahead bassist earlier in the decade, someone to 
hold it down next to Art Blakey, but by this time he evolved to being a true wild
card, someone to give Richard Davis a run for their money in terms of an esoteric
bass space. Workman’s solo here is notably creative and engaging. Towards the end,
Bartz really takes flight over Waits’s exciting churn.

**“UFO”** Cheerful bluesy dominants next to each other, a bit Monk-ish in affect.
Band swings out. Yeah. Cowell gets a good say. At this moment Cowell was truly a
standout alternative to McCoy Tyner, Herbie Hancock, and Chick Corea, able to play
their shared modal language with personality and wit.

**“Lost In The Stars” **A Kurt Weill tune taken on duo by Bartz and Workman. From
the beginning, it is hardly a basic ballad, but a rich exploration of possibility.
Bartz’s heartfelt reading of the melody suspends over fast and abstract bass. (The
idea of “Lost in the Stars” fits in with the “Interstellar” theme of the LP.)

**“Perihelion And Aphelion”** The aphelion is when the Earth is farthest from the
sun; the perihelion is when they are the closest. This story is told musically in
a tempo change from medium waltz to uptempo 4/4. Bartz’s theme honks out some of
the lowest notes on alto, a moment that sounds particularly Coltrane-ish.

![Gary Bartz & Jazz Is Dead - JazzTimes](https://i0.wp.com/cdn2.jazztimes.com/2021/
05/gary-bartz-alan-nahigian.jpg?w=640&ssl=1)

**Charles Tolliver,_ Paper Man _with Herbie Hancock, Ron Carter, and Joe Chambers,
with Gary Bartz joining in on side B**

This session was Tolliver’s first as a leader. It was recorded at Town Sound Studios
in Englewood, which seems to have been a just-down-the-block but black-owned alternative
to Van Gelder’s. Tootie Heath’s _Kawaida_ was also recorded there.

The LP was somewhat belatedly released as _Charles Tolliver and his All-Stars _on
Black Lion in 1971; my first copy was as _Paper Man_ in the Arista/Freedom reissue
series from 1975. In some ways Tolliver’s LP pairs with Woody Shaw’s first album
as a leader, which was tracked for Blue Note in 1965 (and also features Herbie Hancock,
Ron Carter, and Joe Chambers, although all three don’t play as a unit) yet only 
finally released in the ’80s as _In the Beginning_. Another album from the associated
network was 1969’s _Brilliant Circles_ with Stanley Cowell, which also suffered 
from delays; my first copy was again the Arista/Freedom reissue series that had 
_Paper Man_.

If these three notably strong releases from Shaw, Tolliver, and Cowell had been 
presented as soon as the LPs were made from a label with a profile, we might write
jazz history a little differently. Surely these troublesome delays were one reason
Tolliver and Cowell started their own label Strata-East in 1971.

![Lockdown Preview: Charles Tolliver – Echoes Magazine](https://i0.wp.com/echoesmagazine.
co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Charles-Tolliver-770x514.jpg?resize=640%2C427&ssl
=1)

A few Strata-East dates were also tracked at Town Sound Studios, including Cecil
Payne’s _Zodiac._ I really like the way the bass and drums are captured on _Paper
Man_ — indeed, this LP remains one of the best places to check out Joe Chambers —
but the piano is a problem. Hancock doesn’t care, he is full of boundless enthusiasm
on this out-of-tune upright.

As a unit, Hancock/Carter/Chambers are also heard on:

**Sam Rivers _Contour_
 Wayne Shorter _The All-Seeing Eye_ Wayne Shorter _Schizophrenia_
Bobby Hutcherson _Components_

All these Blue Note sessions are fabulous, but they are also all feature compositions
that are quite complicated. Tolliver’s strong and charismatic themes for _Paper 
Man_ are straight to the point, and the rhythm section truly lets the dogs out. 
Incredible session for all three, Hancock, Carter, and Chambers. Tolliver himself
is large and in charge, putting himself right in the league with Woody Shaw and 
Freddie Hubbard.

Pianist George Colligan placed Paper Man in his personal top 10 list and wrote a
blog entry where he goes though the six tunes. Colligan’s comments are on point,
so I will direct readers to his post for the play-by-play.

Summer of ’68. Some serious music was being made!

![Charles Tolliver: Blowing Down The Walls Of Trump's Jericho article @ All  About
Jazz](https://i0.wp.com/s3.amazonaws.com/allaboutjazz/photos/2010/c299ee039bd5d6b9a7df661aaaf410fa.
jpg?w=640&ssl=1)

### _Related_
